Simulating the capture of CO2 from natural gas: New data and improved models for methane+carbon dioxide+methanol

Thomas Hughes, Mohamed Kandil, Brendan Graham, Eric May

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

© 2014 Elsevier Ltd. The simulation of carbon capture unit operations often involves predicting the vapor liquid equilibrium (VLE) for mixtures containing polar, non-polar and quadrupolar compounds. In this work, we investigate how well a simple cubic equation of state (EOS) can predict the results of new low temperature, high-pressure VLE measurements of the ternary methane+carbon dioxide+methanol system, which is important to the Rectisol process used for capturing CO2 from natural gas. The ternary p, T, x measurements presented here are the first such data for this system reported in the open literature. First, predictions made with the Peng Robinson (PR) EOS as implemented in a commercial process simulator were compared to binary p, T, x data measured in this work and also taken from the literature. Significant deviations were found between the measured liquid mole fractions and those predicted with the EOS using the default binary interaction parameters (BIP): the relative standard errors were 39%, 77% and 17% for the methane+methanol, methane+carbon dioxide and methanol+carbon dioxide binaries, respectively. Regression of the PR EOS to the binary VLE data by adjusting the BIPs improved the liquid phase mole fraction predictions for the ternary mixture data by a factor of about 2.5 for methane and methanol. However, improvement by a factor of 4.4 in the carbon dioxide liquid mole fraction was achieved by describing the carbon dioxide+methanol binary with an asymmetric composition and temperature dependent mixing rule and tuning the BIPs therein to VLE data for this binary over a wide temperature range. This reduced the standard error in the liquid phase CO2 mole fractions predicted for the ternary mixture using the optimized model by 79% relative to the default model.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)121-127
JournalInternational Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control
Volume31
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Fingerprint

methanol
natural gas
Natural gas
Carbon dioxide
Methane
Methanol
Equations of state
carbon dioxide
Phase equilibria
methane
liquid
equation of state
Liquids
Carbon capture
Temperature
Tuning
Simulators
prediction
simulator
Chemical analysis

Cite this

@article{1439b7ca55f748d295b030f5ee42018a,
title = "Simulating the capture of CO2 from natural gas: New data and improved models for methane+carbon dioxide+methanol",
abstract = "{\circledC} 2014 Elsevier Ltd. The simulation of carbon capture unit operations often involves predicting the vapor liquid equilibrium (VLE) for mixtures containing polar, non-polar and quadrupolar compounds. In this work, we investigate how well a simple cubic equation of state (EOS) can predict the results of new low temperature, high-pressure VLE measurements of the ternary methane+carbon dioxide+methanol system, which is important to the Rectisol process used for capturing CO2 from natural gas. The ternary p, T, x measurements presented here are the first such data for this system reported in the open literature. First, predictions made with the Peng Robinson (PR) EOS as implemented in a commercial process simulator were compared to binary p, T, x data measured in this work and also taken from the literature. Significant deviations were found between the measured liquid mole fractions and those predicted with the EOS using the default binary interaction parameters (BIP): the relative standard errors were 39{\%}, 77{\%} and 17{\%} for the methane+methanol, methane+carbon dioxide and methanol+carbon dioxide binaries, respectively. Regression of the PR EOS to the binary VLE data by adjusting the BIPs improved the liquid phase mole fraction predictions for the ternary mixture data by a factor of about 2.5 for methane and methanol. However, improvement by a factor of 4.4 in the carbon dioxide liquid mole fraction was achieved by describing the carbon dioxide+methanol binary with an asymmetric composition and temperature dependent mixing rule and tuning the BIPs therein to VLE data for this binary over a wide temperature range. This reduced the standard error in the liquid phase CO2 mole fractions predicted for the ternary mixture using the optimized model by 79{\%} relative to the default model.",
author = "Thomas Hughes and Mohamed Kandil and Brendan Graham and Eric May",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1016/j.ijggc.2014.09.020",
language = "English",
volume = "31",
pages = "121--127",
journal = "International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control",
issn = "1750-5836",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Simulating the capture of CO2 from natural gas: New data and improved models for methane+carbon dioxide+methanol

AU - Hughes, Thomas

AU - Kandil, Mohamed

AU - Graham, Brendan

AU - May, Eric

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - © 2014 Elsevier Ltd. The simulation of carbon capture unit operations often involves predicting the vapor liquid equilibrium (VLE) for mixtures containing polar, non-polar and quadrupolar compounds. In this work, we investigate how well a simple cubic equation of state (EOS) can predict the results of new low temperature, high-pressure VLE measurements of the ternary methane+carbon dioxide+methanol system, which is important to the Rectisol process used for capturing CO2 from natural gas. The ternary p, T, x measurements presented here are the first such data for this system reported in the open literature. First, predictions made with the Peng Robinson (PR) EOS as implemented in a commercial process simulator were compared to binary p, T, x data measured in this work and also taken from the literature. Significant deviations were found between the measured liquid mole fractions and those predicted with the EOS using the default binary interaction parameters (BIP): the relative standard errors were 39%, 77% and 17% for the methane+methanol, methane+carbon dioxide and methanol+carbon dioxide binaries, respectively. Regression of the PR EOS to the binary VLE data by adjusting the BIPs improved the liquid phase mole fraction predictions for the ternary mixture data by a factor of about 2.5 for methane and methanol. However, improvement by a factor of 4.4 in the carbon dioxide liquid mole fraction was achieved by describing the carbon dioxide+methanol binary with an asymmetric composition and temperature dependent mixing rule and tuning the BIPs therein to VLE data for this binary over a wide temperature range. This reduced the standard error in the liquid phase CO2 mole fractions predicted for the ternary mixture using the optimized model by 79% relative to the default model.

AB - © 2014 Elsevier Ltd. The simulation of carbon capture unit operations often involves predicting the vapor liquid equilibrium (VLE) for mixtures containing polar, non-polar and quadrupolar compounds. In this work, we investigate how well a simple cubic equation of state (EOS) can predict the results of new low temperature, high-pressure VLE measurements of the ternary methane+carbon dioxide+methanol system, which is important to the Rectisol process used for capturing CO2 from natural gas. The ternary p, T, x measurements presented here are the first such data for this system reported in the open literature. First, predictions made with the Peng Robinson (PR) EOS as implemented in a commercial process simulator were compared to binary p, T, x data measured in this work and also taken from the literature. Significant deviations were found between the measured liquid mole fractions and those predicted with the EOS using the default binary interaction parameters (BIP): the relative standard errors were 39%, 77% and 17% for the methane+methanol, methane+carbon dioxide and methanol+carbon dioxide binaries, respectively. Regression of the PR EOS to the binary VLE data by adjusting the BIPs improved the liquid phase mole fraction predictions for the ternary mixture data by a factor of about 2.5 for methane and methanol. However, improvement by a factor of 4.4 in the carbon dioxide liquid mole fraction was achieved by describing the carbon dioxide+methanol binary with an asymmetric composition and temperature dependent mixing rule and tuning the BIPs therein to VLE data for this binary over a wide temperature range. This reduced the standard error in the liquid phase CO2 mole fractions predicted for the ternary mixture using the optimized model by 79% relative to the default model.

U2 - 10.1016/j.ijggc.2014.09.020

DO - 10.1016/j.ijggc.2014.09.020

M3 - Article

VL - 31

SP - 121

EP - 127

JO - International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control

JF - International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control

SN - 1750-5836

ER -