Rhetoric versus reality: the role of research in deconstructing concepts of caring

Dawn Freshwater, Jane Cahill, Philip Esterhuizen, Tessa Muncey, Helen Smith

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Our aim was to employ a critical analytic lens to explicate the role of nursing research in supporting the notion of caring realities. To do this, we used case exemplars to illustrate the infusion of such discourses. The first exemplar examines the fundamental concept of caring: using Florence Nightingale's Notes on Nursing, the case study surfaces caring as originally grounded in ritualized practice and subsequently describes its transmutation, via competing discourses, to a more holistic concept. It is argued that in the many and varied attempts to define the dynamic concept of care, caring has now become paradoxically, a more fragmented concept despite attempts to render it more holistic and inclusive. In the second exemplar, one of the authors draws on her personal experience of the gap between theory and practice, so pronounced that it pushed the author to revisit the concept of evidence-based practice and nursing education. In our third and final exemplar, we refer to the absence of knowledge and practice generated through natural enquiry and curiosity, an absence which has led to production of corporate led rhetoric. Drawing together the central arguments of the three exemplars, we reflect on the influential role of nursing research in enabling the deconstruction of taken for granted assumptions such as caring, evidence-based practice and empowerment; assumptions which have been generated by discourses riddled with confusion and alienation from the reality of practice and the natural spirit of professional enquiry.

Original languageEnglish
Article numbere12176
JournalNursing Philosophy
Volume18
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2017

Fingerprint

Research
Nursing Research
Evidence-Based Practice
Evidence-Based Nursing
Confusion
Exploratory Behavior
Nursing Education
Lenses
Nursing
Power (Psychology)

Cite this

Freshwater, Dawn ; Cahill, Jane ; Esterhuizen, Philip ; Muncey, Tessa ; Smith, Helen. / Rhetoric versus reality : the role of research in deconstructing concepts of caring. In: Nursing Philosophy. 2017 ; Vol. 18, No. 4.
@article{774952992b43462e9e556e6bdc5b8a22,
title = "Rhetoric versus reality: the role of research in deconstructing concepts of caring",
abstract = "Our aim was to employ a critical analytic lens to explicate the role of nursing research in supporting the notion of caring realities. To do this, we used case exemplars to illustrate the infusion of such discourses. The first exemplar examines the fundamental concept of caring: using Florence Nightingale's Notes on Nursing, the case study surfaces caring as originally grounded in ritualized practice and subsequently describes its transmutation, via competing discourses, to a more holistic concept. It is argued that in the many and varied attempts to define the dynamic concept of care, caring has now become paradoxically, a more fragmented concept despite attempts to render it more holistic and inclusive. In the second exemplar, one of the authors draws on her personal experience of the gap between theory and practice, so pronounced that it pushed the author to revisit the concept of evidence-based practice and nursing education. In our third and final exemplar, we refer to the absence of knowledge and practice generated through natural enquiry and curiosity, an absence which has led to production of corporate led rhetoric. Drawing together the central arguments of the three exemplars, we reflect on the influential role of nursing research in enabling the deconstruction of taken for granted assumptions such as caring, evidence-based practice and empowerment; assumptions which have been generated by discourses riddled with confusion and alienation from the reality of practice and the natural spirit of professional enquiry.",
keywords = "Caring, Discourses, Evidence-based practice, Knowledge production, Nursing practice, Nursing research, Professional enquiry, Rhetoric",
author = "Dawn Freshwater and Jane Cahill and Philip Esterhuizen and Tessa Muncey and Helen Smith",
year = "2017",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1111/nup.12176",
language = "English",
volume = "18",
journal = "Nursing Philosophy",
issn = "1466-7681",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "4",

}

Rhetoric versus reality : the role of research in deconstructing concepts of caring. / Freshwater, Dawn; Cahill, Jane; Esterhuizen, Philip; Muncey, Tessa; Smith, Helen.

In: Nursing Philosophy, Vol. 18, No. 4, e12176, 10.2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Rhetoric versus reality

T2 - the role of research in deconstructing concepts of caring

AU - Freshwater, Dawn

AU - Cahill, Jane

AU - Esterhuizen, Philip

AU - Muncey, Tessa

AU - Smith, Helen

PY - 2017/10

Y1 - 2017/10

N2 - Our aim was to employ a critical analytic lens to explicate the role of nursing research in supporting the notion of caring realities. To do this, we used case exemplars to illustrate the infusion of such discourses. The first exemplar examines the fundamental concept of caring: using Florence Nightingale's Notes on Nursing, the case study surfaces caring as originally grounded in ritualized practice and subsequently describes its transmutation, via competing discourses, to a more holistic concept. It is argued that in the many and varied attempts to define the dynamic concept of care, caring has now become paradoxically, a more fragmented concept despite attempts to render it more holistic and inclusive. In the second exemplar, one of the authors draws on her personal experience of the gap between theory and practice, so pronounced that it pushed the author to revisit the concept of evidence-based practice and nursing education. In our third and final exemplar, we refer to the absence of knowledge and practice generated through natural enquiry and curiosity, an absence which has led to production of corporate led rhetoric. Drawing together the central arguments of the three exemplars, we reflect on the influential role of nursing research in enabling the deconstruction of taken for granted assumptions such as caring, evidence-based practice and empowerment; assumptions which have been generated by discourses riddled with confusion and alienation from the reality of practice and the natural spirit of professional enquiry.

AB - Our aim was to employ a critical analytic lens to explicate the role of nursing research in supporting the notion of caring realities. To do this, we used case exemplars to illustrate the infusion of such discourses. The first exemplar examines the fundamental concept of caring: using Florence Nightingale's Notes on Nursing, the case study surfaces caring as originally grounded in ritualized practice and subsequently describes its transmutation, via competing discourses, to a more holistic concept. It is argued that in the many and varied attempts to define the dynamic concept of care, caring has now become paradoxically, a more fragmented concept despite attempts to render it more holistic and inclusive. In the second exemplar, one of the authors draws on her personal experience of the gap between theory and practice, so pronounced that it pushed the author to revisit the concept of evidence-based practice and nursing education. In our third and final exemplar, we refer to the absence of knowledge and practice generated through natural enquiry and curiosity, an absence which has led to production of corporate led rhetoric. Drawing together the central arguments of the three exemplars, we reflect on the influential role of nursing research in enabling the deconstruction of taken for granted assumptions such as caring, evidence-based practice and empowerment; assumptions which have been generated by discourses riddled with confusion and alienation from the reality of practice and the natural spirit of professional enquiry.

KW - Caring

KW - Discourses

KW - Evidence-based practice

KW - Knowledge production

KW - Nursing practice

KW - Nursing research

KW - Professional enquiry

KW - Rhetoric

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85019972919&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/nup.12176

DO - 10.1111/nup.12176

M3 - Article

VL - 18

JO - Nursing Philosophy

JF - Nursing Philosophy

SN - 1466-7681

IS - 4

M1 - e12176

ER -