Non-market valuation: praise, protest and performance in environmental policy

Research output: Chapter in Book/Conference paperConference paper

Abstract

A vast literature exists on environmental non-market valuation (NMV) research. The large volume of academic research appears to contrast with the actual use of non-market values in policymaking. Here, we investigate how, when, and why NMV is used to inform environmental policy in Australia. NMV researchers were surveyed about studies they believed to have influenced policy. Then, decision makers were interviewed about the level of influence that NMV has or has not had on their decisions. We find that researchers’ perceptions of the influence that non-market valuation has on policy and decision making are overly optimistic. Interviews with decision makers suggest that non-market valuation is not used widely or consistently in decision making. In fact, the majority of decision makers are unfamiliar with non-market valuation techniques. In spite of this, decision makers do view the concept of non-market valuation positively, and see that it could benefit environmental policy. Implications include that economists need to improve their communication of non-market valuation to decision makers, and offer simpler decision support frameworks in which the values can be used and interpreted for policy.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publication57th Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society
Place of PublicationAustralia
PublisherAustralian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society
Publication statusPublished - 2013
Event57th Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society - Sydney, Australia
Duration: 5 Feb 20138 Feb 2013
Conference number: 57
http://www.aares.org.au/imis_prod/AARES2016/Events/Past_AARES_Events/AARES2016/Event/List_of_Past_Ann_Conferences.aspx?hkey=697a397a-82c9-4453-b9ed-1391712b45d4

Conference

Conference57th Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society
Abbreviated titleAARES Annual Conference
CountryAustralia
CitySydney
Period5/02/138/02/13
Internet address

Fingerprint

Environmental policy
Protest
Non-market valuation
Decision maker
Policy making
Decision making
Communication
Nonmarket values
Academic research
Economists
Decision support

Cite this

Rogers, A., Kragt, M., Gibson, F., Pannell, D., Burton, M., & Petersen, E. (2013). Non-market valuation: praise, protest and performance in environmental policy . In 57th Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society Australia: Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society.
Rogers, Abbie ; Kragt, Marit ; Gibson, Fiona ; Pannell, David ; Burton, Michael ; Petersen, Elizabeth. / Non-market valuation : praise, protest and performance in environmental policy . 57th Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society. Australia : Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society, 2013.
@inproceedings{5e0ed6f211c142c2a32c113601cf8b1e,
title = "Non-market valuation: praise, protest and performance in environmental policy",
abstract = "A vast literature exists on environmental non-market valuation (NMV) research. The large volume of academic research appears to contrast with the actual use of non-market values in policymaking. Here, we investigate how, when, and why NMV is used to inform environmental policy in Australia. NMV researchers were surveyed about studies they believed to have influenced policy. Then, decision makers were interviewed about the level of influence that NMV has or has not had on their decisions. We find that researchers’ perceptions of the influence that non-market valuation has on policy and decision making are overly optimistic. Interviews with decision makers suggest that non-market valuation is not used widely or consistently in decision making. In fact, the majority of decision makers are unfamiliar with non-market valuation techniques. In spite of this, decision makers do view the concept of non-market valuation positively, and see that it could benefit environmental policy. Implications include that economists need to improve their communication of non-market valuation to decision makers, and offer simpler decision support frameworks in which the values can be used and interpreted for policy.",
author = "Abbie Rogers and Marit Kragt and Fiona Gibson and David Pannell and Michael Burton and Elizabeth Petersen",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
booktitle = "57th Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society",
publisher = "Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society",

}

Rogers, A, Kragt, M, Gibson, F, Pannell, D, Burton, M & Petersen, E 2013, Non-market valuation: praise, protest and performance in environmental policy . in 57th Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society. Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society, Australia, 57th Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society, Sydney, Australia, 5/02/13.

Non-market valuation : praise, protest and performance in environmental policy . / Rogers, Abbie; Kragt, Marit; Gibson, Fiona; Pannell, David; Burton, Michael; Petersen, Elizabeth.

57th Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society. Australia : Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society, 2013.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Conference paperConference paper

TY - GEN

T1 - Non-market valuation

T2 - praise, protest and performance in environmental policy

AU - Rogers, Abbie

AU - Kragt, Marit

AU - Gibson, Fiona

AU - Pannell, David

AU - Burton, Michael

AU - Petersen, Elizabeth

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - A vast literature exists on environmental non-market valuation (NMV) research. The large volume of academic research appears to contrast with the actual use of non-market values in policymaking. Here, we investigate how, when, and why NMV is used to inform environmental policy in Australia. NMV researchers were surveyed about studies they believed to have influenced policy. Then, decision makers were interviewed about the level of influence that NMV has or has not had on their decisions. We find that researchers’ perceptions of the influence that non-market valuation has on policy and decision making are overly optimistic. Interviews with decision makers suggest that non-market valuation is not used widely or consistently in decision making. In fact, the majority of decision makers are unfamiliar with non-market valuation techniques. In spite of this, decision makers do view the concept of non-market valuation positively, and see that it could benefit environmental policy. Implications include that economists need to improve their communication of non-market valuation to decision makers, and offer simpler decision support frameworks in which the values can be used and interpreted for policy.

AB - A vast literature exists on environmental non-market valuation (NMV) research. The large volume of academic research appears to contrast with the actual use of non-market values in policymaking. Here, we investigate how, when, and why NMV is used to inform environmental policy in Australia. NMV researchers were surveyed about studies they believed to have influenced policy. Then, decision makers were interviewed about the level of influence that NMV has or has not had on their decisions. We find that researchers’ perceptions of the influence that non-market valuation has on policy and decision making are overly optimistic. Interviews with decision makers suggest that non-market valuation is not used widely or consistently in decision making. In fact, the majority of decision makers are unfamiliar with non-market valuation techniques. In spite of this, decision makers do view the concept of non-market valuation positively, and see that it could benefit environmental policy. Implications include that economists need to improve their communication of non-market valuation to decision makers, and offer simpler decision support frameworks in which the values can be used and interpreted for policy.

UR - https://ideas.repec.org/s/ags/aare13.html

M3 - Conference paper

BT - 57th Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society

PB - Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society

CY - Australia

ER -

Rogers A, Kragt M, Gibson F, Pannell D, Burton M, Petersen E. Non-market valuation: praise, protest and performance in environmental policy . In 57th Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society. Australia: Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society. 2013