Monitoring bioeroding sponges: Using rubble, quadrat, or intercept surveys?

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

19 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

© 2015 Marine Biological Laboratory. Relating to recent environmental changes, bioerosion rates of calcium carbonate materials appear to be increasing worldwide, often driven by sponges that cause bioerosion and are recognized bioindicators for coral reef health. Various field methods were compared to encourage more vigorous research on bioeroding sponges and their inclusion in major monitoring projects. The rubble technique developed by Holmes et al. (2000) had drawbacks often due to small specimen sizes: it was time-costly, generated large variation, and created a biased impression about dominant species. Quadrat surveys were most rapid but overestimated cover of small specimens. Line intercepts are recommended as easiest, least spatially biased, and most accurate, especially when comparing results from different observers. Intercepts required fewer samples and provided the best statistical efficiency, evidenced by better significances and test power. Bioeroding sponge abundances and biodiversities are influenced by water depth, sediment quality, and most importantly by availability of suitable attached substrate. Any related data should thus be standardized to amount of suitable substrate to allow comparison between different environments, concentrating on dominant, easily recognized species to avoid bias due to experience of observers.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)137-155
JournalBiological Bulletin
Volume228
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Fingerprint

Porifera
monitoring
concentrating
calcium carbonate
Coral Reefs
coral reefs
Calcium Carbonate
Biodiversity
biodiversity
sediments
methodology
Water
water
testing
Health
Research
sampling
Surveys and Questionnaires

Cite this

@article{8ce397e790c14201921fb2e3b20914c4,
title = "Monitoring bioeroding sponges: Using rubble, quadrat, or intercept surveys?",
abstract = "{\circledC} 2015 Marine Biological Laboratory. Relating to recent environmental changes, bioerosion rates of calcium carbonate materials appear to be increasing worldwide, often driven by sponges that cause bioerosion and are recognized bioindicators for coral reef health. Various field methods were compared to encourage more vigorous research on bioeroding sponges and their inclusion in major monitoring projects. The rubble technique developed by Holmes et al. (2000) had drawbacks often due to small specimen sizes: it was time-costly, generated large variation, and created a biased impression about dominant species. Quadrat surveys were most rapid but overestimated cover of small specimens. Line intercepts are recommended as easiest, least spatially biased, and most accurate, especially when comparing results from different observers. Intercepts required fewer samples and provided the best statistical efficiency, evidenced by better significances and test power. Bioeroding sponge abundances and biodiversities are influenced by water depth, sediment quality, and most importantly by availability of suitable attached substrate. Any related data should thus be standardized to amount of suitable substrate to allow comparison between different environments, concentrating on dominant, easily recognized species to avoid bias due to experience of observers.",
author = "Christine Schonberg",
year = "2015",
language = "English",
volume = "228",
pages = "137--155",
journal = "Biological Bulletin",
issn = "0006-3185",
publisher = "Marine Biological Laboratory",
number = "2",

}

Monitoring bioeroding sponges: Using rubble, quadrat, or intercept surveys? / Schonberg, Christine.

In: Biological Bulletin, Vol. 228, No. 2, 2015, p. 137-155.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Monitoring bioeroding sponges: Using rubble, quadrat, or intercept surveys?

AU - Schonberg, Christine

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - © 2015 Marine Biological Laboratory. Relating to recent environmental changes, bioerosion rates of calcium carbonate materials appear to be increasing worldwide, often driven by sponges that cause bioerosion and are recognized bioindicators for coral reef health. Various field methods were compared to encourage more vigorous research on bioeroding sponges and their inclusion in major monitoring projects. The rubble technique developed by Holmes et al. (2000) had drawbacks often due to small specimen sizes: it was time-costly, generated large variation, and created a biased impression about dominant species. Quadrat surveys were most rapid but overestimated cover of small specimens. Line intercepts are recommended as easiest, least spatially biased, and most accurate, especially when comparing results from different observers. Intercepts required fewer samples and provided the best statistical efficiency, evidenced by better significances and test power. Bioeroding sponge abundances and biodiversities are influenced by water depth, sediment quality, and most importantly by availability of suitable attached substrate. Any related data should thus be standardized to amount of suitable substrate to allow comparison between different environments, concentrating on dominant, easily recognized species to avoid bias due to experience of observers.

AB - © 2015 Marine Biological Laboratory. Relating to recent environmental changes, bioerosion rates of calcium carbonate materials appear to be increasing worldwide, often driven by sponges that cause bioerosion and are recognized bioindicators for coral reef health. Various field methods were compared to encourage more vigorous research on bioeroding sponges and their inclusion in major monitoring projects. The rubble technique developed by Holmes et al. (2000) had drawbacks often due to small specimen sizes: it was time-costly, generated large variation, and created a biased impression about dominant species. Quadrat surveys were most rapid but overestimated cover of small specimens. Line intercepts are recommended as easiest, least spatially biased, and most accurate, especially when comparing results from different observers. Intercepts required fewer samples and provided the best statistical efficiency, evidenced by better significances and test power. Bioeroding sponge abundances and biodiversities are influenced by water depth, sediment quality, and most importantly by availability of suitable attached substrate. Any related data should thus be standardized to amount of suitable substrate to allow comparison between different environments, concentrating on dominant, easily recognized species to avoid bias due to experience of observers.

M3 - Article

VL - 228

SP - 137

EP - 155

JO - Biological Bulletin

JF - Biological Bulletin

SN - 0006-3185

IS - 2

ER -