Modelling shallow and narrow urban salt-wedge estuaries: Evaluation of model performance and sensitivity to optimise input data collection

Dusan Jovanovic, Simone Gelsinari, Louise Bruce, Matthew Hipsey, Ian Teakle, Matthew Barnes, Rhys Coleman, Ana Deletic, David T. Mccarthy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Complex three-dimensional estuarine hydrodynamic models require large quantities of high-resolution data for model forcing and initialisation. The data are often expensive and difficult to collect with high accuracy (e.g. bathymetry data, riverine flows, water depths, etc.). It may be possible to reduce input data requirements, whilst maintaining predictive capabilities. This is the first study that assesses the sensitivity of a three-dimensional hydrodynamic model of a shallow and narrow urban salt-wedge estuary to input data used for model forcing and initialisation. The model was built using the TUFLOW FV modelling platform and its performance was tested against high-resolution water level, flow velocity, vertical salinity and temperature distribution data. A number of scenarios were used in which data used for model forcing and initialisation, including flow rates, salinity and temperature, wind, bed roughness, bathymetry and vertical mesh discretisation were systematically varied. To assess the sensitivity of model outputs, model predictions were compared to the optimised model predictions for ten periods covering different hydrologic and hydrodynamic conditions. The analysis showed that all model outputs (i.e. water level, velocity, temperature and salinity) were influenced by large and localised water inputs. Due to limited wind fetch of narrow water bodies, wind inputs are expected to have limited impact on hydrodynamic model outputs. However, in this study, flow velocity, salinity and temperature outputs were all influenced by wind inputs. Whilst, accurate bathymetry data are considered essential for developing three-dimensional hydrodynamic models of shallow regions, in this study, uncertainty in the bathymetry data had limited influence on model outputs. Removal of stormwater inputs (i.e. 208 stormwater drains), setting constant salinity for fresh water inputs, weekly averaging of temperature and errors in bathymetry all had minimal impact on model outputs. The results of this case-study can help inform future modelling exercises of narrow and shallow salt-wedge estuaries by focussing efforts on the most important input data. This would potentially lead to substantial reductions in cost and time needed to set up the model.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)9-27
Number of pages19
JournalEstuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science
Volume217
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 5 Feb 2019

Fingerprint

estuaries
estuary
salt
salts
modeling
bathymetry
hydrodynamics
salinity
evaluation
stormwater
temperature
flow velocity
water level
surface water level
bed roughness
fetch
prediction
roughness
drain
water depth

Cite this

Jovanovic, Dusan ; Gelsinari, Simone ; Bruce, Louise ; Hipsey, Matthew ; Teakle, Ian ; Barnes, Matthew ; Coleman, Rhys ; Deletic, Ana ; Mccarthy, David T. / Modelling shallow and narrow urban salt-wedge estuaries : Evaluation of model performance and sensitivity to optimise input data collection. In: Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science. 2019 ; Vol. 217. pp. 9-27.
@article{a88971764fcf4f69884e79cc9a723db8,
title = "Modelling shallow and narrow urban salt-wedge estuaries: Evaluation of model performance and sensitivity to optimise input data collection",
abstract = "Complex three-dimensional estuarine hydrodynamic models require large quantities of high-resolution data for model forcing and initialisation. The data are often expensive and difficult to collect with high accuracy (e.g. bathymetry data, riverine flows, water depths, etc.). It may be possible to reduce input data requirements, whilst maintaining predictive capabilities. This is the first study that assesses the sensitivity of a three-dimensional hydrodynamic model of a shallow and narrow urban salt-wedge estuary to input data used for model forcing and initialisation. The model was built using the TUFLOW FV modelling platform and its performance was tested against high-resolution water level, flow velocity, vertical salinity and temperature distribution data. A number of scenarios were used in which data used for model forcing and initialisation, including flow rates, salinity and temperature, wind, bed roughness, bathymetry and vertical mesh discretisation were systematically varied. To assess the sensitivity of model outputs, model predictions were compared to the optimised model predictions for ten periods covering different hydrologic and hydrodynamic conditions. The analysis showed that all model outputs (i.e. water level, velocity, temperature and salinity) were influenced by large and localised water inputs. Due to limited wind fetch of narrow water bodies, wind inputs are expected to have limited impact on hydrodynamic model outputs. However, in this study, flow velocity, salinity and temperature outputs were all influenced by wind inputs. Whilst, accurate bathymetry data are considered essential for developing three-dimensional hydrodynamic models of shallow regions, in this study, uncertainty in the bathymetry data had limited influence on model outputs. Removal of stormwater inputs (i.e. 208 stormwater drains), setting constant salinity for fresh water inputs, weekly averaging of temperature and errors in bathymetry all had minimal impact on model outputs. The results of this case-study can help inform future modelling exercises of narrow and shallow salt-wedge estuaries by focussing efforts on the most important input data. This would potentially lead to substantial reductions in cost and time needed to set up the model.",
keywords = "Boundary conditions, Estuary, Numerical modelling, Stormwater, TUFLOW FV, Uncertainty",
author = "Dusan Jovanovic and Simone Gelsinari and Louise Bruce and Matthew Hipsey and Ian Teakle and Matthew Barnes and Rhys Coleman and Ana Deletic and Mccarthy, {David T.}",
year = "2019",
month = "2",
day = "5",
doi = "10.1016/j.ecss.2018.10.022",
language = "English",
volume = "217",
pages = "9--27",
journal = "Estuarine Coastal and Shelf Science",
issn = "0272-7714",
publisher = "Academic Press",

}

Modelling shallow and narrow urban salt-wedge estuaries : Evaluation of model performance and sensitivity to optimise input data collection. / Jovanovic, Dusan; Gelsinari, Simone; Bruce, Louise; Hipsey, Matthew; Teakle, Ian; Barnes, Matthew; Coleman, Rhys; Deletic, Ana; Mccarthy, David T.

In: Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science, Vol. 217, 05.02.2019, p. 9-27.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Modelling shallow and narrow urban salt-wedge estuaries

T2 - Evaluation of model performance and sensitivity to optimise input data collection

AU - Jovanovic, Dusan

AU - Gelsinari, Simone

AU - Bruce, Louise

AU - Hipsey, Matthew

AU - Teakle, Ian

AU - Barnes, Matthew

AU - Coleman, Rhys

AU - Deletic, Ana

AU - Mccarthy, David T.

PY - 2019/2/5

Y1 - 2019/2/5

N2 - Complex three-dimensional estuarine hydrodynamic models require large quantities of high-resolution data for model forcing and initialisation. The data are often expensive and difficult to collect with high accuracy (e.g. bathymetry data, riverine flows, water depths, etc.). It may be possible to reduce input data requirements, whilst maintaining predictive capabilities. This is the first study that assesses the sensitivity of a three-dimensional hydrodynamic model of a shallow and narrow urban salt-wedge estuary to input data used for model forcing and initialisation. The model was built using the TUFLOW FV modelling platform and its performance was tested against high-resolution water level, flow velocity, vertical salinity and temperature distribution data. A number of scenarios were used in which data used for model forcing and initialisation, including flow rates, salinity and temperature, wind, bed roughness, bathymetry and vertical mesh discretisation were systematically varied. To assess the sensitivity of model outputs, model predictions were compared to the optimised model predictions for ten periods covering different hydrologic and hydrodynamic conditions. The analysis showed that all model outputs (i.e. water level, velocity, temperature and salinity) were influenced by large and localised water inputs. Due to limited wind fetch of narrow water bodies, wind inputs are expected to have limited impact on hydrodynamic model outputs. However, in this study, flow velocity, salinity and temperature outputs were all influenced by wind inputs. Whilst, accurate bathymetry data are considered essential for developing three-dimensional hydrodynamic models of shallow regions, in this study, uncertainty in the bathymetry data had limited influence on model outputs. Removal of stormwater inputs (i.e. 208 stormwater drains), setting constant salinity for fresh water inputs, weekly averaging of temperature and errors in bathymetry all had minimal impact on model outputs. The results of this case-study can help inform future modelling exercises of narrow and shallow salt-wedge estuaries by focussing efforts on the most important input data. This would potentially lead to substantial reductions in cost and time needed to set up the model.

AB - Complex three-dimensional estuarine hydrodynamic models require large quantities of high-resolution data for model forcing and initialisation. The data are often expensive and difficult to collect with high accuracy (e.g. bathymetry data, riverine flows, water depths, etc.). It may be possible to reduce input data requirements, whilst maintaining predictive capabilities. This is the first study that assesses the sensitivity of a three-dimensional hydrodynamic model of a shallow and narrow urban salt-wedge estuary to input data used for model forcing and initialisation. The model was built using the TUFLOW FV modelling platform and its performance was tested against high-resolution water level, flow velocity, vertical salinity and temperature distribution data. A number of scenarios were used in which data used for model forcing and initialisation, including flow rates, salinity and temperature, wind, bed roughness, bathymetry and vertical mesh discretisation were systematically varied. To assess the sensitivity of model outputs, model predictions were compared to the optimised model predictions for ten periods covering different hydrologic and hydrodynamic conditions. The analysis showed that all model outputs (i.e. water level, velocity, temperature and salinity) were influenced by large and localised water inputs. Due to limited wind fetch of narrow water bodies, wind inputs are expected to have limited impact on hydrodynamic model outputs. However, in this study, flow velocity, salinity and temperature outputs were all influenced by wind inputs. Whilst, accurate bathymetry data are considered essential for developing three-dimensional hydrodynamic models of shallow regions, in this study, uncertainty in the bathymetry data had limited influence on model outputs. Removal of stormwater inputs (i.e. 208 stormwater drains), setting constant salinity for fresh water inputs, weekly averaging of temperature and errors in bathymetry all had minimal impact on model outputs. The results of this case-study can help inform future modelling exercises of narrow and shallow salt-wedge estuaries by focussing efforts on the most important input data. This would potentially lead to substantial reductions in cost and time needed to set up the model.

KW - Boundary conditions

KW - Estuary

KW - Numerical modelling

KW - Stormwater

KW - TUFLOW FV

KW - Uncertainty

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85056477224&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.ecss.2018.10.022

DO - 10.1016/j.ecss.2018.10.022

M3 - Article

VL - 217

SP - 9

EP - 27

JO - Estuarine Coastal and Shelf Science

JF - Estuarine Coastal and Shelf Science

SN - 0272-7714

ER -