TY - JOUR
T1 - Land mines in the field
T2 - A modest proposal for improving the craft of qualitative health research
AU - Thorne, Sally
AU - Darbyshire, Philip
PY - 2005/10
Y1 - 2005/10
N2 - In this commentary, the authors encourage a renewed enthusiasm for attention to quality criteria in qualitative health research by poking fun at what they understand to be patterns and themes emerging from data collected in their respective extensive "fieldwork" experiences within the genre. Conceptualizing some of the particularly problematic interpretive turns as land mines in the field (or, alternatively, missteps in the dance, cracks in the pottery, wrong turns in the journey, weeds in the garden, or dropped stitches in the quilt), they challenge researchers' collective relationship to both factual and metaphoric empirical claims. With a warning to those unaccustomed to self-deprecating humor, the authors challenge all to pay serious heed to what does and does not constitute rigorous, high-quality, empirical science within the qualitative tradition.
AB - In this commentary, the authors encourage a renewed enthusiasm for attention to quality criteria in qualitative health research by poking fun at what they understand to be patterns and themes emerging from data collected in their respective extensive "fieldwork" experiences within the genre. Conceptualizing some of the particularly problematic interpretive turns as land mines in the field (or, alternatively, missteps in the dance, cracks in the pottery, wrong turns in the journey, weeds in the garden, or dropped stitches in the quilt), they challenge researchers' collective relationship to both factual and metaphoric empirical claims. With a warning to those unaccustomed to self-deprecating humor, the authors challenge all to pay serious heed to what does and does not constitute rigorous, high-quality, empirical science within the qualitative tradition.
KW - Data analysis
KW - Empirical science
KW - Interpretation
KW - Qualitative methodology
KW - Quality criteria
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=26444594925&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1177/1049732305278502
DO - 10.1177/1049732305278502
M3 - Article
C2 - 16221882
AN - SCOPUS:26444594925
SN - 1049-7323
VL - 15
SP - 1105
EP - 1113
JO - Qualitative Health Research
JF - Qualitative Health Research
IS - 8
ER -