Impact of the Four-Hour Rule in Western Australian hospitals: Trend analysis of a large record linkage study 2002-2013

Hanh Ngo, Roberto Forero, David Mountain, Daniel Fatovich, Wing Nicola Man, Peter Sprivulis, Mohammed Mohsin, Sam Toloo, Antonio Celenza, Gerard Fitzgerald, Sally McCarthy, Ken Hillman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: In 2009, the Western Australian (WA) Government introduced the Four-Hour Rule (FHR) program. The policy stated that most patients presenting to Emergency Departments (EDs) were to be seen and either admitted, transferred, or discharged within 4 hours. This study utilised de-identified data from five participating hospitals, before and after FHR implementation, to assess the impact of the FHR on several areas of ED functioning. Methods: A state (WA) population-based intervention study design, using longitudinal data obtained from administrative health databases via record linkage methodology, and interrupted time series analysis technique. Findings: There were 3,214,802 ED presentations, corresponding to 1,203,513 ED patients. After the FHR implementation, access block for patients admitted through ED for all five sites showed a significant reduction of up to 13.2% (Rate Ratio 0.868, 95%CI 0.814, 0.925) per quarter. Rate of ED attendances for most hospitals continued to rise throughout the entire study period and were unaffected by the FHR, except for one hospital. Pattern of change in ED re-attendance rate post-FHR was similar to pre-FHR, but the trend reduced for two hospitals. ED occupancy was reduced by 6.2% per quarter post-FHR for the most 'crowded' ED. ED length of stay and ED efficiency improved in four hospitals and deteriorated in one hospital. Time to being seen by ED clinician and Did-Not-Wait rate improved for some hospitals. Admission rates in post-FHR increased, by up to 1% per quarter, for two hospitals where the pre-FHR trend was decreasing. Conclusions: The FHR had a consistent effect on 'flow' measures: significantly reducing ED overcrowding and access block and enhancing ED efficiency. Time-based outcome measures mostly improved with the FHR. There is some evidence of increased ED attendance, but no evidence of increased ED re-attendance. Effects on patient disposition status were mixed. Overall, this reflects the value of investing resources into the ED/hospital system to improve efficiency and patient experience. Further research is required to illuminate the exact mechanisms of the effects of FHR on the ED and hospital functioning across Australia.

Original languageEnglish
Article numbere0193902
Pages (from-to)e0193902
JournalPLoS One
Volume13
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Mar 2018

Fingerprint

Hospital Emergency Service
Time series analysis
time series analysis
experimental design
methodology
Health
Length of Stay

Cite this

Ngo, Hanh ; Forero, Roberto ; Mountain, David ; Fatovich, Daniel ; Man, Wing Nicola ; Sprivulis, Peter ; Mohsin, Mohammed ; Toloo, Sam ; Celenza, Antonio ; Fitzgerald, Gerard ; McCarthy, Sally ; Hillman, Ken. / Impact of the Four-Hour Rule in Western Australian hospitals : Trend analysis of a large record linkage study 2002-2013. In: PLoS One. 2018 ; Vol. 13, No. 3. pp. e0193902.
@article{eca1f6e82ddb4014b166cf2579a5f517,
title = "Impact of the Four-Hour Rule in Western Australian hospitals: Trend analysis of a large record linkage study 2002-2013",
abstract = "Background: In 2009, the Western Australian (WA) Government introduced the Four-Hour Rule (FHR) program. The policy stated that most patients presenting to Emergency Departments (EDs) were to be seen and either admitted, transferred, or discharged within 4 hours. This study utilised de-identified data from five participating hospitals, before and after FHR implementation, to assess the impact of the FHR on several areas of ED functioning. Methods: A state (WA) population-based intervention study design, using longitudinal data obtained from administrative health databases via record linkage methodology, and interrupted time series analysis technique. Findings: There were 3,214,802 ED presentations, corresponding to 1,203,513 ED patients. After the FHR implementation, access block for patients admitted through ED for all five sites showed a significant reduction of up to 13.2{\%} (Rate Ratio 0.868, 95{\%}CI 0.814, 0.925) per quarter. Rate of ED attendances for most hospitals continued to rise throughout the entire study period and were unaffected by the FHR, except for one hospital. Pattern of change in ED re-attendance rate post-FHR was similar to pre-FHR, but the trend reduced for two hospitals. ED occupancy was reduced by 6.2{\%} per quarter post-FHR for the most 'crowded' ED. ED length of stay and ED efficiency improved in four hospitals and deteriorated in one hospital. Time to being seen by ED clinician and Did-Not-Wait rate improved for some hospitals. Admission rates in post-FHR increased, by up to 1{\%} per quarter, for two hospitals where the pre-FHR trend was decreasing. Conclusions: The FHR had a consistent effect on 'flow' measures: significantly reducing ED overcrowding and access block and enhancing ED efficiency. Time-based outcome measures mostly improved with the FHR. There is some evidence of increased ED attendance, but no evidence of increased ED re-attendance. Effects on patient disposition status were mixed. Overall, this reflects the value of investing resources into the ED/hospital system to improve efficiency and patient experience. Further research is required to illuminate the exact mechanisms of the effects of FHR on the ED and hospital functioning across Australia.",
author = "Hanh Ngo and Roberto Forero and David Mountain and Daniel Fatovich and Man, {Wing Nicola} and Peter Sprivulis and Mohammed Mohsin and Sam Toloo and Antonio Celenza and Gerard Fitzgerald and Sally McCarthy and Ken Hillman",
year = "2018",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1371/journal.pone.0193902",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
pages = "e0193902",
journal = "P L o S One",
issn = "1932-6203",
publisher = "Public Library of Science (PLoS)",
number = "3",

}

Ngo, H, Forero, R, Mountain, D, Fatovich, D, Man, WN, Sprivulis, P, Mohsin, M, Toloo, S, Celenza, A, Fitzgerald, G, McCarthy, S & Hillman, K 2018, 'Impact of the Four-Hour Rule in Western Australian hospitals: Trend analysis of a large record linkage study 2002-2013' PLoS One, vol. 13, no. 3, e0193902, pp. e0193902. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0193902

Impact of the Four-Hour Rule in Western Australian hospitals : Trend analysis of a large record linkage study 2002-2013. / Ngo, Hanh; Forero, Roberto; Mountain, David; Fatovich, Daniel; Man, Wing Nicola; Sprivulis, Peter; Mohsin, Mohammed; Toloo, Sam; Celenza, Antonio; Fitzgerald, Gerard; McCarthy, Sally; Hillman, Ken.

In: PLoS One, Vol. 13, No. 3, e0193902, 01.03.2018, p. e0193902.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Impact of the Four-Hour Rule in Western Australian hospitals

T2 - Trend analysis of a large record linkage study 2002-2013

AU - Ngo, Hanh

AU - Forero, Roberto

AU - Mountain, David

AU - Fatovich, Daniel

AU - Man, Wing Nicola

AU - Sprivulis, Peter

AU - Mohsin, Mohammed

AU - Toloo, Sam

AU - Celenza, Antonio

AU - Fitzgerald, Gerard

AU - McCarthy, Sally

AU - Hillman, Ken

PY - 2018/3/1

Y1 - 2018/3/1

N2 - Background: In 2009, the Western Australian (WA) Government introduced the Four-Hour Rule (FHR) program. The policy stated that most patients presenting to Emergency Departments (EDs) were to be seen and either admitted, transferred, or discharged within 4 hours. This study utilised de-identified data from five participating hospitals, before and after FHR implementation, to assess the impact of the FHR on several areas of ED functioning. Methods: A state (WA) population-based intervention study design, using longitudinal data obtained from administrative health databases via record linkage methodology, and interrupted time series analysis technique. Findings: There were 3,214,802 ED presentations, corresponding to 1,203,513 ED patients. After the FHR implementation, access block for patients admitted through ED for all five sites showed a significant reduction of up to 13.2% (Rate Ratio 0.868, 95%CI 0.814, 0.925) per quarter. Rate of ED attendances for most hospitals continued to rise throughout the entire study period and were unaffected by the FHR, except for one hospital. Pattern of change in ED re-attendance rate post-FHR was similar to pre-FHR, but the trend reduced for two hospitals. ED occupancy was reduced by 6.2% per quarter post-FHR for the most 'crowded' ED. ED length of stay and ED efficiency improved in four hospitals and deteriorated in one hospital. Time to being seen by ED clinician and Did-Not-Wait rate improved for some hospitals. Admission rates in post-FHR increased, by up to 1% per quarter, for two hospitals where the pre-FHR trend was decreasing. Conclusions: The FHR had a consistent effect on 'flow' measures: significantly reducing ED overcrowding and access block and enhancing ED efficiency. Time-based outcome measures mostly improved with the FHR. There is some evidence of increased ED attendance, but no evidence of increased ED re-attendance. Effects on patient disposition status were mixed. Overall, this reflects the value of investing resources into the ED/hospital system to improve efficiency and patient experience. Further research is required to illuminate the exact mechanisms of the effects of FHR on the ED and hospital functioning across Australia.

AB - Background: In 2009, the Western Australian (WA) Government introduced the Four-Hour Rule (FHR) program. The policy stated that most patients presenting to Emergency Departments (EDs) were to be seen and either admitted, transferred, or discharged within 4 hours. This study utilised de-identified data from five participating hospitals, before and after FHR implementation, to assess the impact of the FHR on several areas of ED functioning. Methods: A state (WA) population-based intervention study design, using longitudinal data obtained from administrative health databases via record linkage methodology, and interrupted time series analysis technique. Findings: There were 3,214,802 ED presentations, corresponding to 1,203,513 ED patients. After the FHR implementation, access block for patients admitted through ED for all five sites showed a significant reduction of up to 13.2% (Rate Ratio 0.868, 95%CI 0.814, 0.925) per quarter. Rate of ED attendances for most hospitals continued to rise throughout the entire study period and were unaffected by the FHR, except for one hospital. Pattern of change in ED re-attendance rate post-FHR was similar to pre-FHR, but the trend reduced for two hospitals. ED occupancy was reduced by 6.2% per quarter post-FHR for the most 'crowded' ED. ED length of stay and ED efficiency improved in four hospitals and deteriorated in one hospital. Time to being seen by ED clinician and Did-Not-Wait rate improved for some hospitals. Admission rates in post-FHR increased, by up to 1% per quarter, for two hospitals where the pre-FHR trend was decreasing. Conclusions: The FHR had a consistent effect on 'flow' measures: significantly reducing ED overcrowding and access block and enhancing ED efficiency. Time-based outcome measures mostly improved with the FHR. There is some evidence of increased ED attendance, but no evidence of increased ED re-attendance. Effects on patient disposition status were mixed. Overall, this reflects the value of investing resources into the ED/hospital system to improve efficiency and patient experience. Further research is required to illuminate the exact mechanisms of the effects of FHR on the ED and hospital functioning across Australia.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85043775289&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1371/journal.pone.0193902

DO - 10.1371/journal.pone.0193902

M3 - Article

VL - 13

SP - e0193902

JO - P L o S One

JF - P L o S One

SN - 1932-6203

IS - 3

M1 - e0193902

ER -