Grain size matters: Implications for element and isotopic mobility in titanite

Christopher L. Kirkland, C.V. Spaggiari, T. E. Johnson, Robert H. Smithies, Martin Danišík, N. Evans, M. T.D. Wingate, C. Clark, C. Spencer, E. Mikucki, B. J. McDonald

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

23 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The U-Pb isotopic signature of titanite collected across an exhumed refractory lower crustal block within the Albany-Fraser Orogen, Australia, records thermal overprints not apparent in a suite of other U-Pb chronometers. This helps to reconcile a dichotomy within the geochronological record of two adjacent zones within the orogen. The zircon U-Pb record for the older Biranup Zone preserves widespread overprinting at 1225-1140 Ma (Stage II), whereas the younger Fraser Zone records an older 1330-1260 Ma (Stage I) tectonothermal event. Titanite in the Fraser Zone also predominantly records a U-Pb age of 1299 ± 14 Ma, reflecting the interval of closure to radiogenic Pb mobility. Nonetheless, small titanite grains reveal subsequent overprinting with a mean reset age of 1205 ± 16 Ma. By contrast, titanite from metasedimentary rocks within the adjacent Biranup Zone principally record U-Pb ages of 1200-1150 Ma, interpreted as dating cooling after prolonged Stage II metamorphism. Interestingly, titanite also preserves domains with old apparent ages. These domains have a statistically significant association with lower U content and also indicate reduced Sm/Yb ratios and are interpreted to have lost U but acquired HREE (e.g. Yb) more rapidly than MREE (e.g. Sm). The old apparent ages are interpreted as artefacts of a Stage II U redistribution process, leading to unsupported radiogenic Pb. In addition, titanite grain size has a strong effect on the preservation or resetting of metamorphic U-Pb ages. Thermochronological modelling based on apparent age versus grain size relationships indicates that complete resetting of small titanite grains requires overprinting temperatures of 695-725 °C during Stage II in the Fraser Zone. This result is similar to estimates from the Biranup Zone based on phase equilibrium modelling that indicates pressures and temperatures of 6.5-8.5 kbar and 675-725 °C. An in situ U-Pb analysis strategy for titanite that targets a range of grain sizes has the potential to reveal differential resetting and place important controls on thermal history.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)283-302
Number of pages20
JournalPrecambrian Research
Volume278
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jun 2016
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

titanite
Chronometers
grain size
Phase equilibria
Refractory materials
resetting
overprinting
Rocks
Association reactions
Cooling
Temperature
Hot Temperature
metasedimentary rock
phase equilibrium
modeling
artifact
zircon
metamorphism
temperature
cooling

Cite this

Kirkland, C. L., Spaggiari, C. V., Johnson, T. E., Smithies, R. H., Danišík, M., Evans, N., ... McDonald, B. J. (2016). Grain size matters: Implications for element and isotopic mobility in titanite. Precambrian Research, 278, 283-302. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.precamres.2016.03.002
Kirkland, Christopher L. ; Spaggiari, C.V. ; Johnson, T. E. ; Smithies, Robert H. ; Danišík, Martin ; Evans, N. ; Wingate, M. T.D. ; Clark, C. ; Spencer, C. ; Mikucki, E. ; McDonald, B. J. / Grain size matters : Implications for element and isotopic mobility in titanite. In: Precambrian Research. 2016 ; Vol. 278. pp. 283-302.
@article{2ae1dfeabf8a4ad7816c37806860041f,
title = "Grain size matters: Implications for element and isotopic mobility in titanite",
abstract = "The U-Pb isotopic signature of titanite collected across an exhumed refractory lower crustal block within the Albany-Fraser Orogen, Australia, records thermal overprints not apparent in a suite of other U-Pb chronometers. This helps to reconcile a dichotomy within the geochronological record of two adjacent zones within the orogen. The zircon U-Pb record for the older Biranup Zone preserves widespread overprinting at 1225-1140 Ma (Stage II), whereas the younger Fraser Zone records an older 1330-1260 Ma (Stage I) tectonothermal event. Titanite in the Fraser Zone also predominantly records a U-Pb age of 1299 ± 14 Ma, reflecting the interval of closure to radiogenic Pb mobility. Nonetheless, small titanite grains reveal subsequent overprinting with a mean reset age of 1205 ± 16 Ma. By contrast, titanite from metasedimentary rocks within the adjacent Biranup Zone principally record U-Pb ages of 1200-1150 Ma, interpreted as dating cooling after prolonged Stage II metamorphism. Interestingly, titanite also preserves domains with old apparent ages. These domains have a statistically significant association with lower U content and also indicate reduced Sm/Yb ratios and are interpreted to have lost U but acquired HREE (e.g. Yb) more rapidly than MREE (e.g. Sm). The old apparent ages are interpreted as artefacts of a Stage II U redistribution process, leading to unsupported radiogenic Pb. In addition, titanite grain size has a strong effect on the preservation or resetting of metamorphic U-Pb ages. Thermochronological modelling based on apparent age versus grain size relationships indicates that complete resetting of small titanite grains requires overprinting temperatures of 695-725 °C during Stage II in the Fraser Zone. This result is similar to estimates from the Biranup Zone based on phase equilibrium modelling that indicates pressures and temperatures of 6.5-8.5 kbar and 675-725 °C. An in situ U-Pb analysis strategy for titanite that targets a range of grain sizes has the potential to reveal differential resetting and place important controls on thermal history.",
keywords = "Albany-Fraser orogen, Closure temperature, Phase equilibrium modelling, Thermochronological modelling, Titanite, Uranium loss",
author = "Kirkland, {Christopher L.} and C.V. Spaggiari and Johnson, {T. E.} and Smithies, {Robert H.} and Martin Daniš{\'i}k and N. Evans and Wingate, {M. T.D.} and C. Clark and C. Spencer and E. Mikucki and McDonald, {B. J.}",
year = "2016",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.precamres.2016.03.002",
language = "English",
volume = "278",
pages = "283--302",
journal = "Precambrian Research",
issn = "0301-9268",
publisher = "Pergamon",

}

Kirkland, CL, Spaggiari, CV, Johnson, TE, Smithies, RH, Danišík, M, Evans, N, Wingate, MTD, Clark, C, Spencer, C, Mikucki, E & McDonald, BJ 2016, 'Grain size matters: Implications for element and isotopic mobility in titanite' Precambrian Research, vol. 278, pp. 283-302. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.precamres.2016.03.002

Grain size matters : Implications for element and isotopic mobility in titanite. / Kirkland, Christopher L.; Spaggiari, C.V.; Johnson, T. E.; Smithies, Robert H.; Danišík, Martin; Evans, N.; Wingate, M. T.D.; Clark, C.; Spencer, C.; Mikucki, E.; McDonald, B. J.

In: Precambrian Research, Vol. 278, 01.06.2016, p. 283-302.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Grain size matters

T2 - Implications for element and isotopic mobility in titanite

AU - Kirkland, Christopher L.

AU - Spaggiari, C.V.

AU - Johnson, T. E.

AU - Smithies, Robert H.

AU - Danišík, Martin

AU - Evans, N.

AU - Wingate, M. T.D.

AU - Clark, C.

AU - Spencer, C.

AU - Mikucki, E.

AU - McDonald, B. J.

PY - 2016/6/1

Y1 - 2016/6/1

N2 - The U-Pb isotopic signature of titanite collected across an exhumed refractory lower crustal block within the Albany-Fraser Orogen, Australia, records thermal overprints not apparent in a suite of other U-Pb chronometers. This helps to reconcile a dichotomy within the geochronological record of two adjacent zones within the orogen. The zircon U-Pb record for the older Biranup Zone preserves widespread overprinting at 1225-1140 Ma (Stage II), whereas the younger Fraser Zone records an older 1330-1260 Ma (Stage I) tectonothermal event. Titanite in the Fraser Zone also predominantly records a U-Pb age of 1299 ± 14 Ma, reflecting the interval of closure to radiogenic Pb mobility. Nonetheless, small titanite grains reveal subsequent overprinting with a mean reset age of 1205 ± 16 Ma. By contrast, titanite from metasedimentary rocks within the adjacent Biranup Zone principally record U-Pb ages of 1200-1150 Ma, interpreted as dating cooling after prolonged Stage II metamorphism. Interestingly, titanite also preserves domains with old apparent ages. These domains have a statistically significant association with lower U content and also indicate reduced Sm/Yb ratios and are interpreted to have lost U but acquired HREE (e.g. Yb) more rapidly than MREE (e.g. Sm). The old apparent ages are interpreted as artefacts of a Stage II U redistribution process, leading to unsupported radiogenic Pb. In addition, titanite grain size has a strong effect on the preservation or resetting of metamorphic U-Pb ages. Thermochronological modelling based on apparent age versus grain size relationships indicates that complete resetting of small titanite grains requires overprinting temperatures of 695-725 °C during Stage II in the Fraser Zone. This result is similar to estimates from the Biranup Zone based on phase equilibrium modelling that indicates pressures and temperatures of 6.5-8.5 kbar and 675-725 °C. An in situ U-Pb analysis strategy for titanite that targets a range of grain sizes has the potential to reveal differential resetting and place important controls on thermal history.

AB - The U-Pb isotopic signature of titanite collected across an exhumed refractory lower crustal block within the Albany-Fraser Orogen, Australia, records thermal overprints not apparent in a suite of other U-Pb chronometers. This helps to reconcile a dichotomy within the geochronological record of two adjacent zones within the orogen. The zircon U-Pb record for the older Biranup Zone preserves widespread overprinting at 1225-1140 Ma (Stage II), whereas the younger Fraser Zone records an older 1330-1260 Ma (Stage I) tectonothermal event. Titanite in the Fraser Zone also predominantly records a U-Pb age of 1299 ± 14 Ma, reflecting the interval of closure to radiogenic Pb mobility. Nonetheless, small titanite grains reveal subsequent overprinting with a mean reset age of 1205 ± 16 Ma. By contrast, titanite from metasedimentary rocks within the adjacent Biranup Zone principally record U-Pb ages of 1200-1150 Ma, interpreted as dating cooling after prolonged Stage II metamorphism. Interestingly, titanite also preserves domains with old apparent ages. These domains have a statistically significant association with lower U content and also indicate reduced Sm/Yb ratios and are interpreted to have lost U but acquired HREE (e.g. Yb) more rapidly than MREE (e.g. Sm). The old apparent ages are interpreted as artefacts of a Stage II U redistribution process, leading to unsupported radiogenic Pb. In addition, titanite grain size has a strong effect on the preservation or resetting of metamorphic U-Pb ages. Thermochronological modelling based on apparent age versus grain size relationships indicates that complete resetting of small titanite grains requires overprinting temperatures of 695-725 °C during Stage II in the Fraser Zone. This result is similar to estimates from the Biranup Zone based on phase equilibrium modelling that indicates pressures and temperatures of 6.5-8.5 kbar and 675-725 °C. An in situ U-Pb analysis strategy for titanite that targets a range of grain sizes has the potential to reveal differential resetting and place important controls on thermal history.

KW - Albany-Fraser orogen

KW - Closure temperature

KW - Phase equilibrium modelling

KW - Thermochronological modelling

KW - Titanite

KW - Uranium loss

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84962419421&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.precamres.2016.03.002

DO - 10.1016/j.precamres.2016.03.002

M3 - Article

VL - 278

SP - 283

EP - 302

JO - Precambrian Research

JF - Precambrian Research

SN - 0301-9268

ER -

Kirkland CL, Spaggiari CV, Johnson TE, Smithies RH, Danišík M, Evans N et al. Grain size matters: Implications for element and isotopic mobility in titanite. Precambrian Research. 2016 Jun 1;278:283-302. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.precamres.2016.03.002