Field-scale spatial variability of saturated hydraulic conductivity on a recently constructed artificial ecosystem

W. Gwenzi, Christoph Hinz, Karen Holmes, I.R. Phillips, Ian Mullins

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    36 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Saturated hydraulic conductivity (K-s) influences water storage and movement, and is a key parameter of water and solute transport models. Systematic field evaluation of K-s and its spatial variability for recently constructed artificial ecosystems is still lacking. The objectives of the present study were; (1) to determine saturated hydraulic conductivity of an artificial ecosystem using field methods (Philip-Dunne, and Guelph permeameters), and compare their results to the constant-head laboratory method; (2) to evaluate the spatial variability of K-s using univariate and geostatistical analyses, and (3) to evaluate the ability of five pedotransfer functions to predict K-s. The results showed that K-s varied significantly (p <0.05) among methods, probably reflecting differences in scales of measurement, flow geometry, assumptions in computation routines and inherent disturbances during sampling. Mean K-s values were very high for all methods (38.6-77.9 m day(-1)) exceeding values for natural sandy soils by several orders of magnitude. The high K-s values and low coefficients of variation (26-44%) were comparable to that of well-sorted unconsolidated marine sands. Geostatistical analysis revealed a spatial structure in surface K-s data described by a spherical model with a correlation range of 8 m. The resulting kriged map of surface K-s showed alternating bands of high and low values, consistent with surface structures created by wheel tracks of construction equipment Vertical K-s was also spatially structured, with a short correlation range of 40 cm, presumably indicative of layering caused by post-construction mobilization and deposition of fine particles. K-s was linearly and negatively correlated with dry soil bulk density (rho(b)) (r(2) = 0.73), and to a lesser extent silt plus clay percentage (Si + C) (r(2) = 0.21). Combining both rho(b) and Si + C significantly (p <0.05) improved the relationship and gave the best predictor of K-s (r(2) = 0.76). However, evaluation of five PTFs developed for natural soils showed that they all underestimated K-s by an order of magnitude, suggesting that application of water balance simulation models based on such PTFs to the present study site may constitute a bias in model outputs. Overall, the study demonstrated the influence of material handling, construction procedures and post-construction processes on the magnitude and spatial variability of K-s on a recently constructed artificial ecosystem. These unique hydraulic properties may have profound impacts on soil moisture storage, plant water relations and water balance fluxes on artificial ecosystems, particularly where such landforms are intended to restore pre-disturbance ecological and hydrological functions. (C) 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)43-56
    JournalGeoderma
    Volume166
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2011

    Fingerprint

    artificial ecosystem
    saturated hydraulic conductivity
    hydraulic conductivity
    ecosystems
    water balance
    water budget
    wheel tracks
    plant water relations
    materials handling
    permeameters
    pedotransfer function
    disturbance
    pedotransfer functions
    permeameter
    plant-water relations
    laboratory method
    field method
    flow measurement
    landforms
    hydraulic property

    Cite this

    Gwenzi, W. ; Hinz, Christoph ; Holmes, Karen ; Phillips, I.R. ; Mullins, Ian. / Field-scale spatial variability of saturated hydraulic conductivity on a recently constructed artificial ecosystem. In: Geoderma. 2011 ; Vol. 166. pp. 43-56.
    @article{5d626617755e4cc49094eb6cab85d619,
    title = "Field-scale spatial variability of saturated hydraulic conductivity on a recently constructed artificial ecosystem",
    abstract = "Saturated hydraulic conductivity (K-s) influences water storage and movement, and is a key parameter of water and solute transport models. Systematic field evaluation of K-s and its spatial variability for recently constructed artificial ecosystems is still lacking. The objectives of the present study were; (1) to determine saturated hydraulic conductivity of an artificial ecosystem using field methods (Philip-Dunne, and Guelph permeameters), and compare their results to the constant-head laboratory method; (2) to evaluate the spatial variability of K-s using univariate and geostatistical analyses, and (3) to evaluate the ability of five pedotransfer functions to predict K-s. The results showed that K-s varied significantly (p <0.05) among methods, probably reflecting differences in scales of measurement, flow geometry, assumptions in computation routines and inherent disturbances during sampling. Mean K-s values were very high for all methods (38.6-77.9 m day(-1)) exceeding values for natural sandy soils by several orders of magnitude. The high K-s values and low coefficients of variation (26-44{\%}) were comparable to that of well-sorted unconsolidated marine sands. Geostatistical analysis revealed a spatial structure in surface K-s data described by a spherical model with a correlation range of 8 m. The resulting kriged map of surface K-s showed alternating bands of high and low values, consistent with surface structures created by wheel tracks of construction equipment Vertical K-s was also spatially structured, with a short correlation range of 40 cm, presumably indicative of layering caused by post-construction mobilization and deposition of fine particles. K-s was linearly and negatively correlated with dry soil bulk density (rho(b)) (r(2) = 0.73), and to a lesser extent silt plus clay percentage (Si + C) (r(2) = 0.21). Combining both rho(b) and Si + C significantly (p <0.05) improved the relationship and gave the best predictor of K-s (r(2) = 0.76). However, evaluation of five PTFs developed for natural soils showed that they all underestimated K-s by an order of magnitude, suggesting that application of water balance simulation models based on such PTFs to the present study site may constitute a bias in model outputs. Overall, the study demonstrated the influence of material handling, construction procedures and post-construction processes on the magnitude and spatial variability of K-s on a recently constructed artificial ecosystem. These unique hydraulic properties may have profound impacts on soil moisture storage, plant water relations and water balance fluxes on artificial ecosystems, particularly where such landforms are intended to restore pre-disturbance ecological and hydrological functions. (C) 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.",
    author = "W. Gwenzi and Christoph Hinz and Karen Holmes and I.R. Phillips and Ian Mullins",
    year = "2011",
    doi = "10.1016/j.geoderma.2011.06.010",
    language = "English",
    volume = "166",
    pages = "43--56",
    journal = "Geoderma",
    issn = "0016-7061",
    publisher = "Pergamon",

    }

    Field-scale spatial variability of saturated hydraulic conductivity on a recently constructed artificial ecosystem. / Gwenzi, W.; Hinz, Christoph; Holmes, Karen; Phillips, I.R.; Mullins, Ian.

    In: Geoderma, Vol. 166, 2011, p. 43-56.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Field-scale spatial variability of saturated hydraulic conductivity on a recently constructed artificial ecosystem

    AU - Gwenzi, W.

    AU - Hinz, Christoph

    AU - Holmes, Karen

    AU - Phillips, I.R.

    AU - Mullins, Ian

    PY - 2011

    Y1 - 2011

    N2 - Saturated hydraulic conductivity (K-s) influences water storage and movement, and is a key parameter of water and solute transport models. Systematic field evaluation of K-s and its spatial variability for recently constructed artificial ecosystems is still lacking. The objectives of the present study were; (1) to determine saturated hydraulic conductivity of an artificial ecosystem using field methods (Philip-Dunne, and Guelph permeameters), and compare their results to the constant-head laboratory method; (2) to evaluate the spatial variability of K-s using univariate and geostatistical analyses, and (3) to evaluate the ability of five pedotransfer functions to predict K-s. The results showed that K-s varied significantly (p <0.05) among methods, probably reflecting differences in scales of measurement, flow geometry, assumptions in computation routines and inherent disturbances during sampling. Mean K-s values were very high for all methods (38.6-77.9 m day(-1)) exceeding values for natural sandy soils by several orders of magnitude. The high K-s values and low coefficients of variation (26-44%) were comparable to that of well-sorted unconsolidated marine sands. Geostatistical analysis revealed a spatial structure in surface K-s data described by a spherical model with a correlation range of 8 m. The resulting kriged map of surface K-s showed alternating bands of high and low values, consistent with surface structures created by wheel tracks of construction equipment Vertical K-s was also spatially structured, with a short correlation range of 40 cm, presumably indicative of layering caused by post-construction mobilization and deposition of fine particles. K-s was linearly and negatively correlated with dry soil bulk density (rho(b)) (r(2) = 0.73), and to a lesser extent silt plus clay percentage (Si + C) (r(2) = 0.21). Combining both rho(b) and Si + C significantly (p <0.05) improved the relationship and gave the best predictor of K-s (r(2) = 0.76). However, evaluation of five PTFs developed for natural soils showed that they all underestimated K-s by an order of magnitude, suggesting that application of water balance simulation models based on such PTFs to the present study site may constitute a bias in model outputs. Overall, the study demonstrated the influence of material handling, construction procedures and post-construction processes on the magnitude and spatial variability of K-s on a recently constructed artificial ecosystem. These unique hydraulic properties may have profound impacts on soil moisture storage, plant water relations and water balance fluxes on artificial ecosystems, particularly where such landforms are intended to restore pre-disturbance ecological and hydrological functions. (C) 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

    AB - Saturated hydraulic conductivity (K-s) influences water storage and movement, and is a key parameter of water and solute transport models. Systematic field evaluation of K-s and its spatial variability for recently constructed artificial ecosystems is still lacking. The objectives of the present study were; (1) to determine saturated hydraulic conductivity of an artificial ecosystem using field methods (Philip-Dunne, and Guelph permeameters), and compare their results to the constant-head laboratory method; (2) to evaluate the spatial variability of K-s using univariate and geostatistical analyses, and (3) to evaluate the ability of five pedotransfer functions to predict K-s. The results showed that K-s varied significantly (p <0.05) among methods, probably reflecting differences in scales of measurement, flow geometry, assumptions in computation routines and inherent disturbances during sampling. Mean K-s values were very high for all methods (38.6-77.9 m day(-1)) exceeding values for natural sandy soils by several orders of magnitude. The high K-s values and low coefficients of variation (26-44%) were comparable to that of well-sorted unconsolidated marine sands. Geostatistical analysis revealed a spatial structure in surface K-s data described by a spherical model with a correlation range of 8 m. The resulting kriged map of surface K-s showed alternating bands of high and low values, consistent with surface structures created by wheel tracks of construction equipment Vertical K-s was also spatially structured, with a short correlation range of 40 cm, presumably indicative of layering caused by post-construction mobilization and deposition of fine particles. K-s was linearly and negatively correlated with dry soil bulk density (rho(b)) (r(2) = 0.73), and to a lesser extent silt plus clay percentage (Si + C) (r(2) = 0.21). Combining both rho(b) and Si + C significantly (p <0.05) improved the relationship and gave the best predictor of K-s (r(2) = 0.76). However, evaluation of five PTFs developed for natural soils showed that they all underestimated K-s by an order of magnitude, suggesting that application of water balance simulation models based on such PTFs to the present study site may constitute a bias in model outputs. Overall, the study demonstrated the influence of material handling, construction procedures and post-construction processes on the magnitude and spatial variability of K-s on a recently constructed artificial ecosystem. These unique hydraulic properties may have profound impacts on soil moisture storage, plant water relations and water balance fluxes on artificial ecosystems, particularly where such landforms are intended to restore pre-disturbance ecological and hydrological functions. (C) 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

    U2 - 10.1016/j.geoderma.2011.06.010

    DO - 10.1016/j.geoderma.2011.06.010

    M3 - Article

    VL - 166

    SP - 43

    EP - 56

    JO - Geoderma

    JF - Geoderma

    SN - 0016-7061

    ER -