Critical Networks

Paul Watt, Sarah Collins

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This article examines the idea of Critical Networks' as a way of studying the relational structures that shaped music criticism in the long nineteenth century. We argue that the personal, institutional and international networks that supported the dissemination of critical ideas about music are worthy of study in themselves, as they can yield insights beyond prevailing methodologies that centre on individual cases. Focusing on the institutional culture of music criticism means looking beyond the work of individual critics and the content or influence of their views, towards the structures that determined the authoritativeness of those views and the impact of these structures in shaping the operation of critical discourse on music at the time. Examining these networks and how they operated around particular periodicals, tracing transnational exchanges of both ideas and critics, and uncovering the various ideological alliances that were forged or contested within critical networks, can not only provide a thicker context for our understanding of historical ideas about music, but it can also challenge current views about the history of our discipline and the kinds of structures that condition our own ideas about music and music history.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)3-8
Number of pages6
JournalNineteenth Century Music Review
Volume14
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2017

Cite this

Watt, Paul ; Collins, Sarah. / Critical Networks. In: Nineteenth Century Music Review. 2017 ; Vol. 14, No. 1. pp. 3-8.
@article{52686363caa2464098c44434d5886c23,
title = "Critical Networks",
abstract = "This article examines the idea of Critical Networks' as a way of studying the relational structures that shaped music criticism in the long nineteenth century. We argue that the personal, institutional and international networks that supported the dissemination of critical ideas about music are worthy of study in themselves, as they can yield insights beyond prevailing methodologies that centre on individual cases. Focusing on the institutional culture of music criticism means looking beyond the work of individual critics and the content or influence of their views, towards the structures that determined the authoritativeness of those views and the impact of these structures in shaping the operation of critical discourse on music at the time. Examining these networks and how they operated around particular periodicals, tracing transnational exchanges of both ideas and critics, and uncovering the various ideological alliances that were forged or contested within critical networks, can not only provide a thicker context for our understanding of historical ideas about music, but it can also challenge current views about the history of our discipline and the kinds of structures that condition our own ideas about music and music history.",
author = "Paul Watt and Sarah Collins",
year = "2017",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1017/S1479409816000252",
language = "English",
volume = "14",
pages = "3--8",
journal = "Nineteenth Century Music Review",
issn = "1479-4098",
publisher = "Cambridge University Press",
number = "1",

}

Critical Networks. / Watt, Paul; Collins, Sarah.

In: Nineteenth Century Music Review, Vol. 14, No. 1, 04.2017, p. 3-8.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Critical Networks

AU - Watt, Paul

AU - Collins, Sarah

PY - 2017/4

Y1 - 2017/4

N2 - This article examines the idea of Critical Networks' as a way of studying the relational structures that shaped music criticism in the long nineteenth century. We argue that the personal, institutional and international networks that supported the dissemination of critical ideas about music are worthy of study in themselves, as they can yield insights beyond prevailing methodologies that centre on individual cases. Focusing on the institutional culture of music criticism means looking beyond the work of individual critics and the content or influence of their views, towards the structures that determined the authoritativeness of those views and the impact of these structures in shaping the operation of critical discourse on music at the time. Examining these networks and how they operated around particular periodicals, tracing transnational exchanges of both ideas and critics, and uncovering the various ideological alliances that were forged or contested within critical networks, can not only provide a thicker context for our understanding of historical ideas about music, but it can also challenge current views about the history of our discipline and the kinds of structures that condition our own ideas about music and music history.

AB - This article examines the idea of Critical Networks' as a way of studying the relational structures that shaped music criticism in the long nineteenth century. We argue that the personal, institutional and international networks that supported the dissemination of critical ideas about music are worthy of study in themselves, as they can yield insights beyond prevailing methodologies that centre on individual cases. Focusing on the institutional culture of music criticism means looking beyond the work of individual critics and the content or influence of their views, towards the structures that determined the authoritativeness of those views and the impact of these structures in shaping the operation of critical discourse on music at the time. Examining these networks and how they operated around particular periodicals, tracing transnational exchanges of both ideas and critics, and uncovering the various ideological alliances that were forged or contested within critical networks, can not only provide a thicker context for our understanding of historical ideas about music, but it can also challenge current views about the history of our discipline and the kinds of structures that condition our own ideas about music and music history.

U2 - 10.1017/S1479409816000252

DO - 10.1017/S1479409816000252

M3 - Article

VL - 14

SP - 3

EP - 8

JO - Nineteenth Century Music Review

JF - Nineteenth Century Music Review

SN - 1479-4098

IS - 1

ER -