Constructing gender in the press: The case of Audrey Jacob

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Although violent crime committed by women was not common in the early twentieth century in Australia, stories of women’s crime were useful for selling newspapers. By comparing the previously unexamined case notes of Arthur Haynes, defence counsel in R v Audrey Campbell Jacob, with press reports of the case, this article shows that these reports could also be deliberately manipulated by counsel. Haynes used the press as part of his strategy to construct a feminine identity and a narrative of victimisation for his client. This finding is significant because juries used news reports to form their views on legal matters, which had implications for the verdict in this case. Additionally, Haynes successfully used this narrative to mount a defence of the ‘unwritten law’. Established scholarship indicates that full acquittals for so-called honour killings did not occur in Australia; however, this article finds that R v Audrey Campbell Jacob is a rare example of a full acquittal granted in Australia for such a killing.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)58-84
Number of pages27
JournalLaw & History
Volume6
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Fingerprint

gender
narrative
news report
violent crime
selling
honor
victimization
newspaper
twentieth century
offense
Law

Cite this

@article{8884f495855c4ca190df17466be25def,
title = "Constructing gender in the press: The case of Audrey Jacob",
abstract = "Although violent crime committed by women was not common in the early twentieth century in Australia, stories of women’s crime were useful for selling newspapers. By comparing the previously unexamined case notes of Arthur Haynes, defence counsel in R v Audrey Campbell Jacob, with press reports of the case, this article shows that these reports could also be deliberately manipulated by counsel. Haynes used the press as part of his strategy to construct a feminine identity and a narrative of victimisation for his client. This finding is significant because juries used news reports to form their views on legal matters, which had implications for the verdict in this case. Additionally, Haynes successfully used this narrative to mount a defence of the ‘unwritten law’. Established scholarship indicates that full acquittals for so-called honour killings did not occur in Australia; however, this article finds that R v Audrey Campbell Jacob is a rare example of a full acquittal granted in Australia for such a killing.",
keywords = "female offenders, honour killings, the press, courts, femininity",
author = "Caroline Ingram",
year = "2019",
language = "English",
volume = "6",
pages = "58--84",
journal = "Law & History",
issn = "1177-3170",
number = "1",

}

Constructing gender in the press : The case of Audrey Jacob. / Ingram, Caroline.

In: Law & History, Vol. 6, No. 1, 2019, p. 58-84.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Constructing gender in the press

T2 - The case of Audrey Jacob

AU - Ingram, Caroline

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Although violent crime committed by women was not common in the early twentieth century in Australia, stories of women’s crime were useful for selling newspapers. By comparing the previously unexamined case notes of Arthur Haynes, defence counsel in R v Audrey Campbell Jacob, with press reports of the case, this article shows that these reports could also be deliberately manipulated by counsel. Haynes used the press as part of his strategy to construct a feminine identity and a narrative of victimisation for his client. This finding is significant because juries used news reports to form their views on legal matters, which had implications for the verdict in this case. Additionally, Haynes successfully used this narrative to mount a defence of the ‘unwritten law’. Established scholarship indicates that full acquittals for so-called honour killings did not occur in Australia; however, this article finds that R v Audrey Campbell Jacob is a rare example of a full acquittal granted in Australia for such a killing.

AB - Although violent crime committed by women was not common in the early twentieth century in Australia, stories of women’s crime were useful for selling newspapers. By comparing the previously unexamined case notes of Arthur Haynes, defence counsel in R v Audrey Campbell Jacob, with press reports of the case, this article shows that these reports could also be deliberately manipulated by counsel. Haynes used the press as part of his strategy to construct a feminine identity and a narrative of victimisation for his client. This finding is significant because juries used news reports to form their views on legal matters, which had implications for the verdict in this case. Additionally, Haynes successfully used this narrative to mount a defence of the ‘unwritten law’. Established scholarship indicates that full acquittals for so-called honour killings did not occur in Australia; however, this article finds that R v Audrey Campbell Jacob is a rare example of a full acquittal granted in Australia for such a killing.

KW - female offenders

KW - honour killings

KW - the press

KW - courts

KW - femininity

M3 - Article

VL - 6

SP - 58

EP - 84

JO - Law & History

JF - Law & History

SN - 1177-3170

IS - 1

ER -