Can leaf area index and biomass be estimated from Braun-Blanquet cover scores in tropical forests?

T.F. Döbert, Bruce Webber, J.B. Sugau, K.J.M. Dickinson, Raphael Didham

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    7 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    © 2015 International Association for Vegetation Science. Questions: The loss and degradation of tropical forests is having severe impacts on the dynamics of understorey plant communities. Understanding these impacts requires efficient ways to measure vegetation change over broad spatial and temporal scales. Leaf area index (LAI) and above-ground biomass are preferred quantitative measures of variation in plant community structure. However, their accurate measurement requires destructive sampling, which can be impractical or inappropriate. Here we test whether semi-quantitative assessment of Braun-Blanquet vegetation cover scores is a reliable proxy for direct quantitative measures of LAI and above-ground biomass of differing plant growth forms (PGF) within tropical forests. Location: Six hundred square kilometre area of tropical lowland rain forest in Sabah, Malaysia. Methods: We sampled understorey rain forest plant communities across a disturbance gradient in 2 × 2 m plots at 301 locations. We used a modified Braun-Blanquet scale to estimate plant cover, destructively harvested all live above-ground biomass up to a height of 2 m, calculated the above-ground biomass of each species from separately processed stem and leaf fractions in each plot, and then calculated LAI using reference measures of specific leaf area for each species. For each of nine PGFs, we regressed LAI and biomass against the nine-point Braun-Blanquet ordinal transform scale (OTS) using linear mixed effects models. Results: We found a simple, uniform logarithmic scaling of LAI with increasing Braun-Blanquet cover classes that was consistent across most PGFs, and with slope estimates close to 1.0. By contrast, no simple scaling relationship was found for above-ground biomass, with most PGFs exhibiting an asymptotic relationship in which the Braun-Blanquet estimates across high cover scores provided almost no resolution of observed variation in empirical biomass measures. Conclusions: We found that the Braun-Blanquet OTS provides a remarkably simple and accurate logarithmic scaling of LAI, but care should be taken in applying scaling rules uniformly across PGFs. In contrast, the Braun-Blanquet OTS shows a more complex relationship with plant above-ground biomass and we caution against its unconditional use for biomass estimation. The findings of this study should be broadly applicable to other ecosystems due to the heterogeneity of plant communities included in this work.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)1043-1053
    JournalJournal of Vegetation Science
    Volume26
    Issue number6
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2015

    Fingerprint

    aboveground biomass
    leaf area index
    tropical forests
    tropical forest
    plant community
    plant communities
    biomass
    transform
    understory
    rain forests
    vegetation
    lowland forests
    growth form
    ground cover plants
    Borneo
    vegetation cover
    Malaysia
    leaf area
    community structure
    stem

    Cite this

    @article{c779cd1904c24f50b579a84f0c33e8ad,
    title = "Can leaf area index and biomass be estimated from Braun-Blanquet cover scores in tropical forests?",
    abstract = "{\circledC} 2015 International Association for Vegetation Science. Questions: The loss and degradation of tropical forests is having severe impacts on the dynamics of understorey plant communities. Understanding these impacts requires efficient ways to measure vegetation change over broad spatial and temporal scales. Leaf area index (LAI) and above-ground biomass are preferred quantitative measures of variation in plant community structure. However, their accurate measurement requires destructive sampling, which can be impractical or inappropriate. Here we test whether semi-quantitative assessment of Braun-Blanquet vegetation cover scores is a reliable proxy for direct quantitative measures of LAI and above-ground biomass of differing plant growth forms (PGF) within tropical forests. Location: Six hundred square kilometre area of tropical lowland rain forest in Sabah, Malaysia. Methods: We sampled understorey rain forest plant communities across a disturbance gradient in 2 × 2 m plots at 301 locations. We used a modified Braun-Blanquet scale to estimate plant cover, destructively harvested all live above-ground biomass up to a height of 2 m, calculated the above-ground biomass of each species from separately processed stem and leaf fractions in each plot, and then calculated LAI using reference measures of specific leaf area for each species. For each of nine PGFs, we regressed LAI and biomass against the nine-point Braun-Blanquet ordinal transform scale (OTS) using linear mixed effects models. Results: We found a simple, uniform logarithmic scaling of LAI with increasing Braun-Blanquet cover classes that was consistent across most PGFs, and with slope estimates close to 1.0. By contrast, no simple scaling relationship was found for above-ground biomass, with most PGFs exhibiting an asymptotic relationship in which the Braun-Blanquet estimates across high cover scores provided almost no resolution of observed variation in empirical biomass measures. Conclusions: We found that the Braun-Blanquet OTS provides a remarkably simple and accurate logarithmic scaling of LAI, but care should be taken in applying scaling rules uniformly across PGFs. In contrast, the Braun-Blanquet OTS shows a more complex relationship with plant above-ground biomass and we caution against its unconditional use for biomass estimation. The findings of this study should be broadly applicable to other ecosystems due to the heterogeneity of plant communities included in this work.",
    author = "T.F. D{\"o}bert and Bruce Webber and J.B. Sugau and K.J.M. Dickinson and Raphael Didham",
    year = "2015",
    doi = "10.1111/jvs.12310",
    language = "English",
    volume = "26",
    pages = "1043--1053",
    journal = "Journal of Vegetation Science",
    issn = "1100-9233",
    publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
    number = "6",

    }

    Can leaf area index and biomass be estimated from Braun-Blanquet cover scores in tropical forests? / Döbert, T.F.; Webber, Bruce; Sugau, J.B.; Dickinson, K.J.M.; Didham, Raphael.

    In: Journal of Vegetation Science, Vol. 26, No. 6, 2015, p. 1043-1053.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Can leaf area index and biomass be estimated from Braun-Blanquet cover scores in tropical forests?

    AU - Döbert, T.F.

    AU - Webber, Bruce

    AU - Sugau, J.B.

    AU - Dickinson, K.J.M.

    AU - Didham, Raphael

    PY - 2015

    Y1 - 2015

    N2 - © 2015 International Association for Vegetation Science. Questions: The loss and degradation of tropical forests is having severe impacts on the dynamics of understorey plant communities. Understanding these impacts requires efficient ways to measure vegetation change over broad spatial and temporal scales. Leaf area index (LAI) and above-ground biomass are preferred quantitative measures of variation in plant community structure. However, their accurate measurement requires destructive sampling, which can be impractical or inappropriate. Here we test whether semi-quantitative assessment of Braun-Blanquet vegetation cover scores is a reliable proxy for direct quantitative measures of LAI and above-ground biomass of differing plant growth forms (PGF) within tropical forests. Location: Six hundred square kilometre area of tropical lowland rain forest in Sabah, Malaysia. Methods: We sampled understorey rain forest plant communities across a disturbance gradient in 2 × 2 m plots at 301 locations. We used a modified Braun-Blanquet scale to estimate plant cover, destructively harvested all live above-ground biomass up to a height of 2 m, calculated the above-ground biomass of each species from separately processed stem and leaf fractions in each plot, and then calculated LAI using reference measures of specific leaf area for each species. For each of nine PGFs, we regressed LAI and biomass against the nine-point Braun-Blanquet ordinal transform scale (OTS) using linear mixed effects models. Results: We found a simple, uniform logarithmic scaling of LAI with increasing Braun-Blanquet cover classes that was consistent across most PGFs, and with slope estimates close to 1.0. By contrast, no simple scaling relationship was found for above-ground biomass, with most PGFs exhibiting an asymptotic relationship in which the Braun-Blanquet estimates across high cover scores provided almost no resolution of observed variation in empirical biomass measures. Conclusions: We found that the Braun-Blanquet OTS provides a remarkably simple and accurate logarithmic scaling of LAI, but care should be taken in applying scaling rules uniformly across PGFs. In contrast, the Braun-Blanquet OTS shows a more complex relationship with plant above-ground biomass and we caution against its unconditional use for biomass estimation. The findings of this study should be broadly applicable to other ecosystems due to the heterogeneity of plant communities included in this work.

    AB - © 2015 International Association for Vegetation Science. Questions: The loss and degradation of tropical forests is having severe impacts on the dynamics of understorey plant communities. Understanding these impacts requires efficient ways to measure vegetation change over broad spatial and temporal scales. Leaf area index (LAI) and above-ground biomass are preferred quantitative measures of variation in plant community structure. However, their accurate measurement requires destructive sampling, which can be impractical or inappropriate. Here we test whether semi-quantitative assessment of Braun-Blanquet vegetation cover scores is a reliable proxy for direct quantitative measures of LAI and above-ground biomass of differing plant growth forms (PGF) within tropical forests. Location: Six hundred square kilometre area of tropical lowland rain forest in Sabah, Malaysia. Methods: We sampled understorey rain forest plant communities across a disturbance gradient in 2 × 2 m plots at 301 locations. We used a modified Braun-Blanquet scale to estimate plant cover, destructively harvested all live above-ground biomass up to a height of 2 m, calculated the above-ground biomass of each species from separately processed stem and leaf fractions in each plot, and then calculated LAI using reference measures of specific leaf area for each species. For each of nine PGFs, we regressed LAI and biomass against the nine-point Braun-Blanquet ordinal transform scale (OTS) using linear mixed effects models. Results: We found a simple, uniform logarithmic scaling of LAI with increasing Braun-Blanquet cover classes that was consistent across most PGFs, and with slope estimates close to 1.0. By contrast, no simple scaling relationship was found for above-ground biomass, with most PGFs exhibiting an asymptotic relationship in which the Braun-Blanquet estimates across high cover scores provided almost no resolution of observed variation in empirical biomass measures. Conclusions: We found that the Braun-Blanquet OTS provides a remarkably simple and accurate logarithmic scaling of LAI, but care should be taken in applying scaling rules uniformly across PGFs. In contrast, the Braun-Blanquet OTS shows a more complex relationship with plant above-ground biomass and we caution against its unconditional use for biomass estimation. The findings of this study should be broadly applicable to other ecosystems due to the heterogeneity of plant communities included in this work.

    U2 - 10.1111/jvs.12310

    DO - 10.1111/jvs.12310

    M3 - Article

    VL - 26

    SP - 1043

    EP - 1053

    JO - Journal of Vegetation Science

    JF - Journal of Vegetation Science

    SN - 1100-9233

    IS - 6

    ER -