Applying the cultural ratchet to a social artefact: The cumulative cultural evolution of a language game

Nicolas Fay, T. Mark Ellison, Kristian Tylén, Riccardo Fusaroli, Bradley Walker, Simon Garrod

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Material artefacts evolve by cumulative cultural evolution (CCE), the accumulation of adaptive modifications over time. We present a large-scale experiment investigating the CCE of a social artefact in transmission chains, each containing 8 adult human participants (N = 408). The social artefact is what Wittgenstein calls a 'language game', the subset of language used to perform a particular activity; in the present study the language game is to communicate a route on a map. Two social learning conditions were compared: Observational Learning and Social Coordinative Learning. Participants tried to accurately communicate a route on a map to the next person in their transmission chain. Over the experimental generations the routes were reproduced with progressively higher accuracy in both conditions, demonstrating the CCE of the language game. The rate of CCE was comparable across conditions, but route reproduction accuracy was consistently higher in the Social Coordination condition compared to the Observation condition. In both conditions performance improved due to the accumulation of adaptive patterns of verbal route descriptions, and the progressive elimination of non-adaptive patterns. Whereas change in the content of the language game was similar across conditions, change to the communication process differed between the Observation and Social Coordination conditions. In conclusion, like material artefacts, social artefacts, in our case the language game, evolve by cumulative cultural evolution.

LanguageEnglish
Pages300-309
JournalEvolution and Human Behavior
Volume39
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2018

Fingerprint

Cultural Evolution
Artifacts
artifact
Language
Social Conditions
learning
Observation
Learning
communication (human)
Reproduction
Route
Artifact
Language Games
Communication
communication

Cite this

Fay, Nicolas ; Ellison, T. Mark ; Tylén, Kristian ; Fusaroli, Riccardo ; Walker, Bradley ; Garrod, Simon. / Applying the cultural ratchet to a social artefact : The cumulative cultural evolution of a language game. In: Evolution and Human Behavior. 2018 ; Vol. 39, No. 3. pp. 300-309.
@article{ccfbf3a6df8546eca75472830b847331,
title = "Applying the cultural ratchet to a social artefact: The cumulative cultural evolution of a language game",
abstract = "Material artefacts evolve by cumulative cultural evolution (CCE), the accumulation of adaptive modifications over time. We present a large-scale experiment investigating the CCE of a social artefact in transmission chains, each containing 8 adult human participants (N = 408). The social artefact is what Wittgenstein calls a 'language game', the subset of language used to perform a particular activity; in the present study the language game is to communicate a route on a map. Two social learning conditions were compared: Observational Learning and Social Coordinative Learning. Participants tried to accurately communicate a route on a map to the next person in their transmission chain. Over the experimental generations the routes were reproduced with progressively higher accuracy in both conditions, demonstrating the CCE of the language game. The rate of CCE was comparable across conditions, but route reproduction accuracy was consistently higher in the Social Coordination condition compared to the Observation condition. In both conditions performance improved due to the accumulation of adaptive patterns of verbal route descriptions, and the progressive elimination of non-adaptive patterns. Whereas change in the content of the language game was similar across conditions, change to the communication process differed between the Observation and Social Coordination conditions. In conclusion, like material artefacts, social artefacts, in our case the language game, evolve by cumulative cultural evolution.",
keywords = "Cultural inheritance, Cultural selection, Cumulative cultural evolution, Human communication, Language evolution, Language game, Map task, Observational learning, Social coordinative learning",
author = "Nicolas Fay and Ellison, {T. Mark} and Kristian Tyl{\'e}n and Riccardo Fusaroli and Bradley Walker and Simon Garrod",
year = "2018",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2018.02.002",
language = "English",
volume = "39",
pages = "300--309",
journal = "Evolution and Human Behavior",
issn = "1090-5138",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "3",

}

Applying the cultural ratchet to a social artefact : The cumulative cultural evolution of a language game. / Fay, Nicolas; Ellison, T. Mark; Tylén, Kristian; Fusaroli, Riccardo; Walker, Bradley; Garrod, Simon.

In: Evolution and Human Behavior, Vol. 39, No. 3, 05.2018, p. 300-309.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Applying the cultural ratchet to a social artefact

T2 - Evolution and Human Behavior

AU - Fay, Nicolas

AU - Ellison, T. Mark

AU - Tylén, Kristian

AU - Fusaroli, Riccardo

AU - Walker, Bradley

AU - Garrod, Simon

PY - 2018/5

Y1 - 2018/5

N2 - Material artefacts evolve by cumulative cultural evolution (CCE), the accumulation of adaptive modifications over time. We present a large-scale experiment investigating the CCE of a social artefact in transmission chains, each containing 8 adult human participants (N = 408). The social artefact is what Wittgenstein calls a 'language game', the subset of language used to perform a particular activity; in the present study the language game is to communicate a route on a map. Two social learning conditions were compared: Observational Learning and Social Coordinative Learning. Participants tried to accurately communicate a route on a map to the next person in their transmission chain. Over the experimental generations the routes were reproduced with progressively higher accuracy in both conditions, demonstrating the CCE of the language game. The rate of CCE was comparable across conditions, but route reproduction accuracy was consistently higher in the Social Coordination condition compared to the Observation condition. In both conditions performance improved due to the accumulation of adaptive patterns of verbal route descriptions, and the progressive elimination of non-adaptive patterns. Whereas change in the content of the language game was similar across conditions, change to the communication process differed between the Observation and Social Coordination conditions. In conclusion, like material artefacts, social artefacts, in our case the language game, evolve by cumulative cultural evolution.

AB - Material artefacts evolve by cumulative cultural evolution (CCE), the accumulation of adaptive modifications over time. We present a large-scale experiment investigating the CCE of a social artefact in transmission chains, each containing 8 adult human participants (N = 408). The social artefact is what Wittgenstein calls a 'language game', the subset of language used to perform a particular activity; in the present study the language game is to communicate a route on a map. Two social learning conditions were compared: Observational Learning and Social Coordinative Learning. Participants tried to accurately communicate a route on a map to the next person in their transmission chain. Over the experimental generations the routes were reproduced with progressively higher accuracy in both conditions, demonstrating the CCE of the language game. The rate of CCE was comparable across conditions, but route reproduction accuracy was consistently higher in the Social Coordination condition compared to the Observation condition. In both conditions performance improved due to the accumulation of adaptive patterns of verbal route descriptions, and the progressive elimination of non-adaptive patterns. Whereas change in the content of the language game was similar across conditions, change to the communication process differed between the Observation and Social Coordination conditions. In conclusion, like material artefacts, social artefacts, in our case the language game, evolve by cumulative cultural evolution.

KW - Cultural inheritance

KW - Cultural selection

KW - Cumulative cultural evolution

KW - Human communication

KW - Language evolution

KW - Language game

KW - Map task

KW - Observational learning

KW - Social coordinative learning

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85042196429&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2018.02.002

DO - 10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2018.02.002

M3 - Article

VL - 39

SP - 300

EP - 309

JO - Evolution and Human Behavior

JF - Evolution and Human Behavior

SN - 1090-5138

IS - 3

ER -