An experimental examination of target based conservation auctions

Peter C. Boxall, Orsolya Perger, Katherine Packman, Marian Weber

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Conservation auctions are increasingly employed to increase the provision of Ecological Goods and Services (EG&S) for achieving environmental goals. Most applications of conservation auctions concern the efficient allocation of a fixed conservation budget. However an important and under-explored application of conservation auctions is in meeting environmental targets, either as part of regulatory compliance by industry or by governments in meeting specified policy objectives. This paper examines the ability of a conservation auction to meet an environmental target. We use experimental economics methods bench marked to a wetlands restoration case study to examine bidder behavior and efficiency in both budget constrained and target constrained auctions when landowners with increasing marginal costs can offer increasing sized bundles of wetland acres. The target constrained auction is characterized by an all or nothing rule, where there is no payout if the target is not met. We find that rent seeking and average cost in the target constrained auction is less than in a budget constrained auction, but that efficiency eroded in repeated rounds suggesting learning effects as participants realize there is no budget cap. Even with learning effects the target based auction out-performs the budget based auction. Adding a reserve price to the target based auction significantly reduced rent seeking but also increased the probability that the target was not met. The results have important implications for auction design in real world settings. (C) 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)592-600
Number of pages9
JournalLand Use Policy
Volume63
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2017

Cite this

Boxall, Peter C. ; Perger, Orsolya ; Packman, Katherine ; Weber, Marian. / An experimental examination of target based conservation auctions. In: Land Use Policy. 2017 ; Vol. 63. pp. 592-600.
@article{e3c7db856b524b5cbeca8039689d7eba,
title = "An experimental examination of target based conservation auctions",
abstract = "Conservation auctions are increasingly employed to increase the provision of Ecological Goods and Services (EG&S) for achieving environmental goals. Most applications of conservation auctions concern the efficient allocation of a fixed conservation budget. However an important and under-explored application of conservation auctions is in meeting environmental targets, either as part of regulatory compliance by industry or by governments in meeting specified policy objectives. This paper examines the ability of a conservation auction to meet an environmental target. We use experimental economics methods bench marked to a wetlands restoration case study to examine bidder behavior and efficiency in both budget constrained and target constrained auctions when landowners with increasing marginal costs can offer increasing sized bundles of wetland acres. The target constrained auction is characterized by an all or nothing rule, where there is no payout if the target is not met. We find that rent seeking and average cost in the target constrained auction is less than in a budget constrained auction, but that efficiency eroded in repeated rounds suggesting learning effects as participants realize there is no budget cap. Even with learning effects the target based auction out-performs the budget based auction. Adding a reserve price to the target based auction significantly reduced rent seeking but also increased the probability that the target was not met. The results have important implications for auction design in real world settings. (C) 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.",
keywords = "Conservation auctions, Environmental target, Experimental economics, Wetland restoration, NONPOINT-SOURCE POLLUTION, CANADIAN PRAIRIES, RESERVE PROGRAM, CONTRACTS, SASKATCHEWAN, PERFORMANCE, INCENTIVES, LICENSES, UNIFORM",
author = "Boxall, {Peter C.} and Orsolya Perger and Katherine Packman and Marian Weber",
year = "2017",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1016/j.landusepol.2015.03.016",
language = "English",
volume = "63",
pages = "592--600",
journal = "Land Use Policy",
issn = "0264-8377",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

An experimental examination of target based conservation auctions. / Boxall, Peter C.; Perger, Orsolya; Packman, Katherine; Weber, Marian.

In: Land Use Policy, Vol. 63, 04.2017, p. 592-600.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - An experimental examination of target based conservation auctions

AU - Boxall, Peter C.

AU - Perger, Orsolya

AU - Packman, Katherine

AU - Weber, Marian

PY - 2017/4

Y1 - 2017/4

N2 - Conservation auctions are increasingly employed to increase the provision of Ecological Goods and Services (EG&S) for achieving environmental goals. Most applications of conservation auctions concern the efficient allocation of a fixed conservation budget. However an important and under-explored application of conservation auctions is in meeting environmental targets, either as part of regulatory compliance by industry or by governments in meeting specified policy objectives. This paper examines the ability of a conservation auction to meet an environmental target. We use experimental economics methods bench marked to a wetlands restoration case study to examine bidder behavior and efficiency in both budget constrained and target constrained auctions when landowners with increasing marginal costs can offer increasing sized bundles of wetland acres. The target constrained auction is characterized by an all or nothing rule, where there is no payout if the target is not met. We find that rent seeking and average cost in the target constrained auction is less than in a budget constrained auction, but that efficiency eroded in repeated rounds suggesting learning effects as participants realize there is no budget cap. Even with learning effects the target based auction out-performs the budget based auction. Adding a reserve price to the target based auction significantly reduced rent seeking but also increased the probability that the target was not met. The results have important implications for auction design in real world settings. (C) 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

AB - Conservation auctions are increasingly employed to increase the provision of Ecological Goods and Services (EG&S) for achieving environmental goals. Most applications of conservation auctions concern the efficient allocation of a fixed conservation budget. However an important and under-explored application of conservation auctions is in meeting environmental targets, either as part of regulatory compliance by industry or by governments in meeting specified policy objectives. This paper examines the ability of a conservation auction to meet an environmental target. We use experimental economics methods bench marked to a wetlands restoration case study to examine bidder behavior and efficiency in both budget constrained and target constrained auctions when landowners with increasing marginal costs can offer increasing sized bundles of wetland acres. The target constrained auction is characterized by an all or nothing rule, where there is no payout if the target is not met. We find that rent seeking and average cost in the target constrained auction is less than in a budget constrained auction, but that efficiency eroded in repeated rounds suggesting learning effects as participants realize there is no budget cap. Even with learning effects the target based auction out-performs the budget based auction. Adding a reserve price to the target based auction significantly reduced rent seeking but also increased the probability that the target was not met. The results have important implications for auction design in real world settings. (C) 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

KW - Conservation auctions

KW - Environmental target

KW - Experimental economics

KW - Wetland restoration

KW - NONPOINT-SOURCE POLLUTION

KW - CANADIAN PRAIRIES

KW - RESERVE PROGRAM

KW - CONTRACTS

KW - SASKATCHEWAN

KW - PERFORMANCE

KW - INCENTIVES

KW - LICENSES

KW - UNIFORM

U2 - 10.1016/j.landusepol.2015.03.016

DO - 10.1016/j.landusepol.2015.03.016

M3 - Article

VL - 63

SP - 592

EP - 600

JO - Land Use Policy

JF - Land Use Policy

SN - 0264-8377

ER -