Advancing the integration of multi-marker metabarcoding data in dietary analysis of trophic generalists

Luís P. da Silva, Vanessa A. Mata, Pedro B. Lopes, Paulo Pereira, Simon N. Jarman, Ricardo J. Lopes, Pedro Beja

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The application of DNA metabarcoding to dietary analysis of trophic generalists requires using multiple markers in order to overcome problems of primer specificity and bias. However, limited attention has been given to the integration of information from multiple markers, particularly when they partly overlap in the taxa amplified, and vary in taxonomic resolution and biases. Here, we test the use of a mix of universal and specific markers, provide criteria to integrate multi-marker metabarcoding data and a python script to implement such criteria and produce a single list of taxa ingested per sample. We then compare the results of dietary analysis based on morphological methods, single markers, and the proposed combination of multiple markers. The study was based on the analysis of 115 faeces from a small passerine, the Black Wheatears (Oenanthe leucura). Morphological analysis detected far fewer plant taxa (12) than either a universal 18S marker (57) or the plant trnL marker (124). This may partly reflect the detection of secondary ingestion by molecular methods. Morphological identification also detected far fewer taxa (23) than when using 18S (91) or the arthropod markers IN16STK (244) and ZBJ (231), though each method missed or underestimated some prey items. Integration of multi-marker data provided far more detailed dietary information than any single marker and estimated higher frequencies of occurrence of all taxa. Overall, our results show the value of integrating data from multiple, taxonomically overlapping markers in an example dietary data set.

Original languageEnglish
JournalMolecular Ecology Resources
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 22 Jul 2019

Fingerprint

generalist
Oenanthe
Boidae
Python
Arthropods
Feces
arthropods
Eating
feces
methodology
ingestion
DNA
marker
analysis
testing
sampling
passerine
arthropod
Datasets

Cite this

da Silva, Luís P. ; Mata, Vanessa A. ; Lopes, Pedro B. ; Pereira, Paulo ; Jarman, Simon N. ; Lopes, Ricardo J. ; Beja, Pedro. / Advancing the integration of multi-marker metabarcoding data in dietary analysis of trophic generalists. In: Molecular Ecology Resources. 2019.
@article{babd5136eb5840bea45783b5e4553f60,
title = "Advancing the integration of multi-marker metabarcoding data in dietary analysis of trophic generalists",
abstract = "The application of DNA metabarcoding to dietary analysis of trophic generalists requires using multiple markers in order to overcome problems of primer specificity and bias. However, limited attention has been given to the integration of information from multiple markers, particularly when they partly overlap in the taxa amplified, and vary in taxonomic resolution and biases. Here, we test the use of a mix of universal and specific markers, provide criteria to integrate multi-marker metabarcoding data and a python script to implement such criteria and produce a single list of taxa ingested per sample. We then compare the results of dietary analysis based on morphological methods, single markers, and the proposed combination of multiple markers. The study was based on the analysis of 115 faeces from a small passerine, the Black Wheatears (Oenanthe leucura). Morphological analysis detected far fewer plant taxa (12) than either a universal 18S marker (57) or the plant trnL marker (124). This may partly reflect the detection of secondary ingestion by molecular methods. Morphological identification also detected far fewer taxa (23) than when using 18S (91) or the arthropod markers IN16STK (244) and ZBJ (231), though each method missed or underestimated some prey items. Integration of multi-marker data provided far more detailed dietary information than any single marker and estimated higher frequencies of occurrence of all taxa. Overall, our results show the value of integrating data from multiple, taxonomically overlapping markers in an example dietary data set.",
keywords = "bird, diet, metabarcoding, morphological identification, overlapping markers, secondary predation",
author = "{da Silva}, {Lu{\'i}s P.} and Mata, {Vanessa A.} and Lopes, {Pedro B.} and Paulo Pereira and Jarman, {Simon N.} and Lopes, {Ricardo J.} and Pedro Beja",
year = "2019",
month = "7",
day = "22",
doi = "10.1111/1755-0998.13060",
language = "English",
journal = "Molecular Ecology Resources",
issn = "1755-098X",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",

}

Advancing the integration of multi-marker metabarcoding data in dietary analysis of trophic generalists. / da Silva, Luís P.; Mata, Vanessa A.; Lopes, Pedro B.; Pereira, Paulo; Jarman, Simon N.; Lopes, Ricardo J.; Beja, Pedro.

In: Molecular Ecology Resources, 22.07.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Advancing the integration of multi-marker metabarcoding data in dietary analysis of trophic generalists

AU - da Silva, Luís P.

AU - Mata, Vanessa A.

AU - Lopes, Pedro B.

AU - Pereira, Paulo

AU - Jarman, Simon N.

AU - Lopes, Ricardo J.

AU - Beja, Pedro

PY - 2019/7/22

Y1 - 2019/7/22

N2 - The application of DNA metabarcoding to dietary analysis of trophic generalists requires using multiple markers in order to overcome problems of primer specificity and bias. However, limited attention has been given to the integration of information from multiple markers, particularly when they partly overlap in the taxa amplified, and vary in taxonomic resolution and biases. Here, we test the use of a mix of universal and specific markers, provide criteria to integrate multi-marker metabarcoding data and a python script to implement such criteria and produce a single list of taxa ingested per sample. We then compare the results of dietary analysis based on morphological methods, single markers, and the proposed combination of multiple markers. The study was based on the analysis of 115 faeces from a small passerine, the Black Wheatears (Oenanthe leucura). Morphological analysis detected far fewer plant taxa (12) than either a universal 18S marker (57) or the plant trnL marker (124). This may partly reflect the detection of secondary ingestion by molecular methods. Morphological identification also detected far fewer taxa (23) than when using 18S (91) or the arthropod markers IN16STK (244) and ZBJ (231), though each method missed or underestimated some prey items. Integration of multi-marker data provided far more detailed dietary information than any single marker and estimated higher frequencies of occurrence of all taxa. Overall, our results show the value of integrating data from multiple, taxonomically overlapping markers in an example dietary data set.

AB - The application of DNA metabarcoding to dietary analysis of trophic generalists requires using multiple markers in order to overcome problems of primer specificity and bias. However, limited attention has been given to the integration of information from multiple markers, particularly when they partly overlap in the taxa amplified, and vary in taxonomic resolution and biases. Here, we test the use of a mix of universal and specific markers, provide criteria to integrate multi-marker metabarcoding data and a python script to implement such criteria and produce a single list of taxa ingested per sample. We then compare the results of dietary analysis based on morphological methods, single markers, and the proposed combination of multiple markers. The study was based on the analysis of 115 faeces from a small passerine, the Black Wheatears (Oenanthe leucura). Morphological analysis detected far fewer plant taxa (12) than either a universal 18S marker (57) or the plant trnL marker (124). This may partly reflect the detection of secondary ingestion by molecular methods. Morphological identification also detected far fewer taxa (23) than when using 18S (91) or the arthropod markers IN16STK (244) and ZBJ (231), though each method missed or underestimated some prey items. Integration of multi-marker data provided far more detailed dietary information than any single marker and estimated higher frequencies of occurrence of all taxa. Overall, our results show the value of integrating data from multiple, taxonomically overlapping markers in an example dietary data set.

KW - bird

KW - diet

KW - metabarcoding

KW - morphological identification

KW - overlapping markers

KW - secondary predation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85071142091&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/1755-0998.13060

DO - 10.1111/1755-0998.13060

M3 - Article

JO - Molecular Ecology Resources

JF - Molecular Ecology Resources

SN - 1755-098X

ER -