A Review of Cost-Benefit Analysis for Freight Projects

Sae Chi, Tom Frost, Ben Ellis

Research output: Chapter in Book/Conference paperConference paper

Abstract

Cost-Benefit Analysis is most often used to evaluate the net impact of a project to the community. The project can be evaluated from the public perspective in an empirical manner using Cost-Benefit Analysis. Measuring net impacts of a freight project can be a complex task, as it can impact the whole freight network including numerous modes of transport. However, the literature review highlighted that there are a number of inconsistencies and disagreements between academic studies of freight project evaluations. This paper reviews the Cost-Benefit Analyses of a number of land freight projects, in order to investigate how freight projects are evaluated in practice. It has a particular focus on the types of benefits that have been quantified in the analysis and the data that has been used to quantify those benefits. The review found that there are significant inconsistencies between case studies with regard to the types of benefits that have been captured in the analysis. It also found that the treatment of some impacts, particularly those impacts to freight companies, need further investigation. Moreover, the availability of rail freight data compared to road freight data is significantly lacking. For the purpose of conducting Cost-Benefit Analysis of freight projects consistently between freight projects, a standardised methodology and clear guidance need to be established and provided. Additionally, this review can serve as a useful reference list for practitioners for the purpose of conducting Cost-Benefit Analysis of freight projects.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationAustralasian Transport Research Forum 2017 Proceedings
Place of PublicationAustralia
PublisherThe Australasian Transport Research Forum
Publication statusPublished - 27 Nov 2017
Externally publishedYes
EventAustralasian Transport Research Forum 2017 - Auckland, New Zealand
Duration: 27 Nov 201729 Nov 2017

Conference

ConferenceAustralasian Transport Research Forum 2017
CountryNew Zealand
CityAuckland
Period27/11/1729/11/17

Fingerprint

Cost benefit analysis
Rails
Availability
Costs
Industry

Cite this

Chi, S., Frost, T., & Ellis, B. (2017). A Review of Cost-Benefit Analysis for Freight Projects. In Australasian Transport Research Forum 2017 Proceedings Australia: The Australasian Transport Research Forum.
Chi, Sae ; Frost, Tom ; Ellis, Ben. / A Review of Cost-Benefit Analysis for Freight Projects. Australasian Transport Research Forum 2017 Proceedings. Australia : The Australasian Transport Research Forum, 2017.
@inproceedings{efea24e475204bbdaa2649611b9224b3,
title = "A Review of Cost-Benefit Analysis for Freight Projects",
abstract = "Cost-Benefit Analysis is most often used to evaluate the net impact of a project to the community. The project can be evaluated from the public perspective in an empirical manner using Cost-Benefit Analysis. Measuring net impacts of a freight project can be a complex task, as it can impact the whole freight network including numerous modes of transport. However, the literature review highlighted that there are a number of inconsistencies and disagreements between academic studies of freight project evaluations. This paper reviews the Cost-Benefit Analyses of a number of land freight projects, in order to investigate how freight projects are evaluated in practice. It has a particular focus on the types of benefits that have been quantified in the analysis and the data that has been used to quantify those benefits. The review found that there are significant inconsistencies between case studies with regard to the types of benefits that have been captured in the analysis. It also found that the treatment of some impacts, particularly those impacts to freight companies, need further investigation. Moreover, the availability of rail freight data compared to road freight data is significantly lacking. For the purpose of conducting Cost-Benefit Analysis of freight projects consistently between freight projects, a standardised methodology and clear guidance need to be established and provided. Additionally, this review can serve as a useful reference list for practitioners for the purpose of conducting Cost-Benefit Analysis of freight projects.",
keywords = "Cost-Benefit Analysis, freight, transport planning, freight investment",
author = "Sae Chi and Tom Frost and Ben Ellis",
year = "2017",
month = "11",
day = "27",
language = "English",
booktitle = "Australasian Transport Research Forum 2017 Proceedings",
publisher = "The Australasian Transport Research Forum",

}

Chi, S, Frost, T & Ellis, B 2017, A Review of Cost-Benefit Analysis for Freight Projects. in Australasian Transport Research Forum 2017 Proceedings. The Australasian Transport Research Forum, Australia, Australasian Transport Research Forum 2017, Auckland, New Zealand, 27/11/17.

A Review of Cost-Benefit Analysis for Freight Projects. / Chi, Sae; Frost, Tom; Ellis, Ben.

Australasian Transport Research Forum 2017 Proceedings. Australia : The Australasian Transport Research Forum, 2017.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Conference paperConference paper

TY - GEN

T1 - A Review of Cost-Benefit Analysis for Freight Projects

AU - Chi, Sae

AU - Frost, Tom

AU - Ellis, Ben

PY - 2017/11/27

Y1 - 2017/11/27

N2 - Cost-Benefit Analysis is most often used to evaluate the net impact of a project to the community. The project can be evaluated from the public perspective in an empirical manner using Cost-Benefit Analysis. Measuring net impacts of a freight project can be a complex task, as it can impact the whole freight network including numerous modes of transport. However, the literature review highlighted that there are a number of inconsistencies and disagreements between academic studies of freight project evaluations. This paper reviews the Cost-Benefit Analyses of a number of land freight projects, in order to investigate how freight projects are evaluated in practice. It has a particular focus on the types of benefits that have been quantified in the analysis and the data that has been used to quantify those benefits. The review found that there are significant inconsistencies between case studies with regard to the types of benefits that have been captured in the analysis. It also found that the treatment of some impacts, particularly those impacts to freight companies, need further investigation. Moreover, the availability of rail freight data compared to road freight data is significantly lacking. For the purpose of conducting Cost-Benefit Analysis of freight projects consistently between freight projects, a standardised methodology and clear guidance need to be established and provided. Additionally, this review can serve as a useful reference list for practitioners for the purpose of conducting Cost-Benefit Analysis of freight projects.

AB - Cost-Benefit Analysis is most often used to evaluate the net impact of a project to the community. The project can be evaluated from the public perspective in an empirical manner using Cost-Benefit Analysis. Measuring net impacts of a freight project can be a complex task, as it can impact the whole freight network including numerous modes of transport. However, the literature review highlighted that there are a number of inconsistencies and disagreements between academic studies of freight project evaluations. This paper reviews the Cost-Benefit Analyses of a number of land freight projects, in order to investigate how freight projects are evaluated in practice. It has a particular focus on the types of benefits that have been quantified in the analysis and the data that has been used to quantify those benefits. The review found that there are significant inconsistencies between case studies with regard to the types of benefits that have been captured in the analysis. It also found that the treatment of some impacts, particularly those impacts to freight companies, need further investigation. Moreover, the availability of rail freight data compared to road freight data is significantly lacking. For the purpose of conducting Cost-Benefit Analysis of freight projects consistently between freight projects, a standardised methodology and clear guidance need to be established and provided. Additionally, this review can serve as a useful reference list for practitioners for the purpose of conducting Cost-Benefit Analysis of freight projects.

KW - Cost-Benefit Analysis

KW - freight

KW - transport planning

KW - freight investment

UR - https://atrf.info/search.aspx?query=peer%20review

M3 - Conference paper

BT - Australasian Transport Research Forum 2017 Proceedings

PB - The Australasian Transport Research Forum

CY - Australia

ER -

Chi S, Frost T, Ellis B. A Review of Cost-Benefit Analysis for Freight Projects. In Australasian Transport Research Forum 2017 Proceedings. Australia: The Australasian Transport Research Forum. 2017