A practical examination of the errors arising in the direct collocation boundary element method for acoustic scattering

Bradley Treeby, Jie Pan

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    12 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    For many engineers and acousticians, the boundary element method (BEM) provides an invaluable tool in the analysis of complex problems. It is particularly well suited for the examination of acoustical problems within large domains. Unsurprisingly, the widespread application of the BEM continues to produce an academic interest in the methodology. New algorithms and techniques are still being proposed, to extend the functionality of the BEM, and to compute the required numerical tasks with greater accuracy and efficiency. However, for a given global error constraint, the actual computational accuracy that is required from the various numerical procedures is not often discussed. Within this context, this paper presents an investigation into the discretisation and computational errors that arise in the BEM for acoustic scattering. First, accurate routines to compute regular, weakly singular, and nearly weakly singular integral kernels are examined. These are then used to illustrate the effect of the requisite boundary discretisation on the global error. The effects of geometric and impedance singularities are also considered. Subsequently, the actual integration accuracy required to maintain a given global error constraint is established. Several regular and irregular scattering examples are investigated, and empirical parameter guidelines are provided.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)1302-1315
    JournalEngineering Analysis with Boundary Elements
    Volume33
    Issue number11
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2009

    Fingerprint

    Acoustic Scattering
    Boundary element method
    Collocation
    Boundary Elements
    Acoustics
    Scattering
    Discretization
    Singular Integrals
    Numerical Procedure
    Impedance
    Irregular
    Continue
    Singularity
    kernel
    Engineers
    Methodology

    Cite this

    @article{0cc1693d110845dd8ac29c0fb9615627,
    title = "A practical examination of the errors arising in the direct collocation boundary element method for acoustic scattering",
    abstract = "For many engineers and acousticians, the boundary element method (BEM) provides an invaluable tool in the analysis of complex problems. It is particularly well suited for the examination of acoustical problems within large domains. Unsurprisingly, the widespread application of the BEM continues to produce an academic interest in the methodology. New algorithms and techniques are still being proposed, to extend the functionality of the BEM, and to compute the required numerical tasks with greater accuracy and efficiency. However, for a given global error constraint, the actual computational accuracy that is required from the various numerical procedures is not often discussed. Within this context, this paper presents an investigation into the discretisation and computational errors that arise in the BEM for acoustic scattering. First, accurate routines to compute regular, weakly singular, and nearly weakly singular integral kernels are examined. These are then used to illustrate the effect of the requisite boundary discretisation on the global error. The effects of geometric and impedance singularities are also considered. Subsequently, the actual integration accuracy required to maintain a given global error constraint is established. Several regular and irregular scattering examples are investigated, and empirical parameter guidelines are provided.",
    author = "Bradley Treeby and Jie Pan",
    year = "2009",
    doi = "10.1016/j.enganabound.2009.06.005",
    language = "English",
    volume = "33",
    pages = "1302--1315",
    journal = "Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements",
    issn = "0955-7997",
    publisher = "Elsevier",
    number = "11",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - A practical examination of the errors arising in the direct collocation boundary element method for acoustic scattering

    AU - Treeby, Bradley

    AU - Pan, Jie

    PY - 2009

    Y1 - 2009

    N2 - For many engineers and acousticians, the boundary element method (BEM) provides an invaluable tool in the analysis of complex problems. It is particularly well suited for the examination of acoustical problems within large domains. Unsurprisingly, the widespread application of the BEM continues to produce an academic interest in the methodology. New algorithms and techniques are still being proposed, to extend the functionality of the BEM, and to compute the required numerical tasks with greater accuracy and efficiency. However, for a given global error constraint, the actual computational accuracy that is required from the various numerical procedures is not often discussed. Within this context, this paper presents an investigation into the discretisation and computational errors that arise in the BEM for acoustic scattering. First, accurate routines to compute regular, weakly singular, and nearly weakly singular integral kernels are examined. These are then used to illustrate the effect of the requisite boundary discretisation on the global error. The effects of geometric and impedance singularities are also considered. Subsequently, the actual integration accuracy required to maintain a given global error constraint is established. Several regular and irregular scattering examples are investigated, and empirical parameter guidelines are provided.

    AB - For many engineers and acousticians, the boundary element method (BEM) provides an invaluable tool in the analysis of complex problems. It is particularly well suited for the examination of acoustical problems within large domains. Unsurprisingly, the widespread application of the BEM continues to produce an academic interest in the methodology. New algorithms and techniques are still being proposed, to extend the functionality of the BEM, and to compute the required numerical tasks with greater accuracy and efficiency. However, for a given global error constraint, the actual computational accuracy that is required from the various numerical procedures is not often discussed. Within this context, this paper presents an investigation into the discretisation and computational errors that arise in the BEM for acoustic scattering. First, accurate routines to compute regular, weakly singular, and nearly weakly singular integral kernels are examined. These are then used to illustrate the effect of the requisite boundary discretisation on the global error. The effects of geometric and impedance singularities are also considered. Subsequently, the actual integration accuracy required to maintain a given global error constraint is established. Several regular and irregular scattering examples are investigated, and empirical parameter guidelines are provided.

    U2 - 10.1016/j.enganabound.2009.06.005

    DO - 10.1016/j.enganabound.2009.06.005

    M3 - Article

    VL - 33

    SP - 1302

    EP - 1315

    JO - Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements

    JF - Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements

    SN - 0955-7997

    IS - 11

    ER -