A comparison of corneal cellular responses after 213-nm compared with 193-nm laser photorefractive keratectomy in rabbits

Purpose: Corneal refractive surgery is typically performed using a 193-nm excimer laser. However, a recently developed 213-nm solid-state (5th harmonic) Nd:YAG laser presents some practical and user safety advantages, although the biological impact of using this wavelength remains poorly characterized. Here, we provide in vivo and in vitro comparisons of the corneal cellular outcomes after irradiation with 213 and 193 nm wavelengths.Methods: New Zealand White rabbits underwent photorefractive keratectomy with -5 diopters and a 6.5-mm optical zone and studied at time points up to 1 year. The development of haze was examined ophthalmologically and by detecting myofibroblasts immunohistochemically. Cell death was quantified using a terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL) assay, and the number of stromal keratocytes undergoing apoptosis estimated histologically. Superoxide dismutase activity was estimated in vitro by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay in irradiated rabbit corneal keratocytes.Results: Our results demonstrate subtle differences in the cellular outcomes after irradiation with 213- and 193-nm lasers, despite similar degrees of corneal haze developing in both treatment groups. In vivo, the 213-nm laser results in more stable stromal cell numbers, implying a more predictable ablation outcome. In vitro, higher levels of superoxide dismutase in corneal keratocytes irradiated with 213 nm compared with 193 nm wavelengths suggest a better endogenous protection against free radicals induced by laser surgery.Conclusions: The more favorable cellular responses after irradiation with 213 nm compared with 193 nm wavelengths are consistent with good clinical outcomes previously reported. Ablation with a 213 nm wavelength may result in better wound healing, leading to a more reliable correction of refractive errors.